Official Niners studs n duds

[Mavster]

Duds: The officials. What a clown performance from them today.

Studs: Crosby for making the garbage officiating a bit less painful.

 

[BrokenArrow]

I cannot help but think the refs were biased.

On one play, they completely miss a helmet-to-helmet spear hit on a helpless receiver called Adams. Then they call a roughing the passer that wouldn’t have been considered out of line at a Pee Wee touch football game between 8 year olds. Garapallo was barely touched by Alexander’s hands. Alexander couldn’t have stopped in mid-air. Nor did Garapallo even fall to the ground.

Then there was the missed intentional grounding of the ball right before half.

Take the bad performance by the refs away and the 49ers don’t come close.

Good game Packers. You beat the 49ers and the refs.

You forgot the bogus PI on Stokes. Simply touching a guy isn't PI if it doesn't impede the receiver's movement. It was a bail-out call and it gave SF 7 points eventually. We outplayed them by a much bigger margin than the score would suggest. Should have been about 30-17.

 

[swhitset]

Nah. King has to earn his way out of dud status. Simply not playing does not do that. He's a dud until he proves otherwise.

well then I hope he just stays a dud on the inactive list.

 

[PackAttack12]

STUDS - Offensive Line and Crosby

Lot of good but I’d bet serious money this OL was gonna get destroyed…negative in a very BIG way. They made this whole game possible.

Just imagine when Bahktiari and Jenkins are back on the left side...

 

[longtimefan]

I cannot help but think the refs were biased.

On one play, they completely miss a helmet-to-helmet spear hit on a helpless receiver called Adams. Then they call a roughing the passer that wouldn’t have been considered out of line at a Pee Wee touch football game between 8 year olds. Garapallo was barely touched by Alexander’s hands. Alexander couldn’t have stopped in mid-air. Nor did Garapallo even fall to the ground.

Then there was the missed intentional grounding of the ball right before half.

Take the bad performance by the refs away and the 49ers don’t come close.

Good game Packers. You beat the 49ers and the refs.

The on air ref expert claimed the way the refs are sitting hurt the adams play.

He claims the back judge couldnt see..I think it was something about how they are positioned now? As compared to before?

 

[PFanCan]

Studs: Crosby and the Offensive Line. Both were excellent tonight.

Duds: Timeouts being wasted.

The challenge was fine, IMO. I don’t get how that call wasn’t reversed. The ball moved a lot due to clear contact with the ground.

 

[PackAttack12]

The on air ref expert claimed the way the refs are sitting hurt the adams play.

He claims the back judge couldnt see..I think it was something about how they are positioned now? As compared to before?

After I watched it for the 4th or 5th time, I see what he was saying. Still unacceptable.

 

[gatorpack]

You forgot the bogus PI on Stokes. Simply touching a guy isn't PI if it doesn't impede the receiver's movement. It was a bail-out call and it gave SF 7 points eventually. We outplayed them by a much bigger margin than the score would suggest. Should have been about 30-17.

There were so many bad calls and no calls it's hard to keep track

 

[longtimefan]

After I watched it for the 4th or 5th time, I see what he was saying. Still unacceptable.

I am 100 percent with you.

Something like that should be able to be reviewed

 

[BrokenArrow]

He claims the back judge couldnt see..I think it was something about how they are positioned now? As compared to before?

Sounded like crap to me. Announcers these days are instructed to always make the officials look good when they can. Looked like lazy officiating.

 

[PackerDNA]

Huh? The run defense was excellent. Their RBs had a total of 44 yards with a 2.9 average.

The key was Gary and Smith containing.
the 49ers couldn't get their signature pitch-wide runs going

 

[C-Lee]

Refs were impossibly bad in this game. This was a classic Packers game where they should have won by like 3-4 scores but it came down to the wire and they pulled it off, and that's been rare in the LaFleur era.

Massive win.

 

[longtimefan]

Sounded like crap to me. Announcers these days are instructed to always make the officials look good when they can. Looked like lazy officiating.

those on air ref do a good job..I dont think they stick up for anyone.

 

[PFanCan]

The on air ref expert claimed the way the refs are sitting hurt the adams play.

He claims the back judge couldnt see..I think it was something about how they are positioned now? As compared to before?

Ok, I didn’t know that.

Its just that, in general, it seems to me that the refs have been very good at calling those types of hits and getting the defenders to modify how they tackle (I.e. not by leading with the crown of your helmet).

 

[realitybytez]

No hands will be raised

I told wife, 31 to 10

my wife is a bit of a psychic. when the packers gave up the td at the end of the first half and i was griping about it, she told me that the packers would win but it would be a very close game.

 

[longtimefan]

When Barnes went out, Niners offense started to make plays

 

[PackerDNA]

what a job by the offensive line and the kids up front.They won the battle against the 49ers front in both the run and pass. physical in the run game, and good job pass blocking. Rogers only sacked once and not under much pressure all night.

 

[longtimefan]

what a job by the offensive line and the kids up front.They won the battle against the 49ers front in both the run and pass. physical in the run game, and good job pass blocking. Rogers only sacked once and not under much pressure all night.

The coaches deserve credit. Robert was blocking Bosa, as was Lazard

 

[PFanCan]

The key was Gary and Smith containing.
the 49ers couldn't get their signature pitch-wide runs going

I noted the same thing. Both ends did an excellent job of forcing the runners to go inside. In week one, we couldn’t contain all game.

 

[JK64]

The whole O line - studs, even if they weren't perfect. Raise your hand if you thought they could do this as a unit against that SF front.

This is the best the O line played in 3 games. Interesting.

 

[PackerDNA]

Studs
Crosby - not just game winner but saved a TD on long kick return.

Crosby might be the best tackling kicker in the NFL

 

[PFanCan]

my wife is a bit of a psychic. when the packers gave up the td at the end of the first half and i was griping about it, she told me that the packers would win but it would be a very close game.

Take her to Vegas. Roulette.

 

[JK64]

I cannot help but think the refs were biased.

On one play, they completely miss a helmet-to-helmet spear hit on a helpless receiver called Adams. Then they call a roughing the passer that wouldn’t have been considered out of line at a Pee Wee touch football game between 8 year olds. Garapallo was barely touched by Alexander’s hands. Alexander couldn’t have stopped in mid-air. Nor did Garapallo even fall to the ground.

Then there was the missed intentional grounding of the ball right before half.

Take the bad performance by the refs away and the 49ers don’t come close.

Good game Packers. You beat the 49ers and the refs.

Honestly, I thought we were in for one of those horrible ref jobs in SF, per usual. We were well on our way to one of those jobs.

 

[PackerDNA]

The coaches deserve credit. Robert was blocking Bosa, as was Lazard

great plan by the coaches and executed perfectly by the line.

 

[PFanCan]

The coaches deserve credit. Robert was blocking Bosa, as was Lazard

Bosa started the game on fire, but whatever adjustments the Packers made… it worked. Didn’t hear his name much after the first quarter.