I'm not a believer in Goff. I think he is only capable of so much. He is surrounded by talent, though, and he gets the job done.
I like Campbell, but he sure has made some poor coaching decisions. I suspect he will learn from his mistakes but am hoping he is just stubborn enough to stick to his methods.
Detroit seems to have vastly improved their scouting staff and player selection process. The days of Matt Millen are long gone. Saw an article on top players under 25 and the Lions had,
#1 Sewel
#6 Hutchinson
#11 St. Brown
#19 LaPorta
#21 Gibbs
There were no Packers. Xavier McKinney maybe should have made the list.
Nobody I can argue with the Lions list, but Gibbs has to be borderline. Likely to be a Lions fan who compiled the list.
As far as the QB situation goes I lean in Love's favor over Goff. Given Love's relative inexperience so far I would hesitate to rank him much above Goff at this time but I do think they are at least equals. What tips the scales in Love's favor to me though is I think there is a lot of room for Love to get much better and really soon, as in 2024. With Goff what you have is pretty much all you are ever going to get.
The Lions may have more top level guys but I think the Packers have more just below that level with the potential to rise type guys. The Lions have St. Brown but I think the packers have at least 3 guys with the potential to surpass him. I'm sure not all of them will but I'll take our group over the Lions although Williams is a huge wild card for the Lions. if he ever develops they will be tough to beat. I think part of St. Brown's success was that they really had no other WRs to take targets away from him. Remember when some people were saying the Packers messed up when their ex WR went off for a few games for the Eagles? Again, someone has to be the number 1. I'm not saying St Brown is in that category but when you are the only guy your stats tend to get padded.
La Porta had a great rookie season but if Kraft or Musgrave had been healthy all year and didn't have each other taking targets away would either of them been very far behind. I don't think so and honestly, right now, I'd rather have our guys than LaPorta.
Sewel and Hutchinson are elite and in their case I don't think we really compare on an individual basis. I don't think we have anyone at their level.
Gibbs also had a great rookie year but Jacobs just missed the cutoff at 26 and I don't think I would put Gibbs over him.
Part of the problem with having a bunch of guys on the best under 25 list is that you don't always have a lot of information to go on. Sewel has 3 years, Hutchinson 2 and St. Brown 3 and they have played at high levels so far but as we all know the Packers had the youngest team in the league last year and probably will again this year. Many of our guys only have 1 or 2 years behind them give them 1 or 2 more and I'll bet a few of them crack that list.