D
Deleted member 6794
Guest
Spitz started 45 games over 5 seasons, a rate of 56%. Marshall Newhouse started 31 games over 3 seasons, a rate of 65%. Starting stats probably aren't the best measuring stick but I get your point.
Colledge is a bubble guy too. He started but was average by most measurements of an offensive lineman. Newhouse started a lot of games for two years, and if I remember, switching from LT to RT. Spits similarly played most positions on the OL, never nailing one down, and then served as a backup his final year before leaving in FA.
I personally don't think any of them underwhelmed or overwhelmed...or whelmed. They were just guys who showed enough to get a shot at starting, but were not worth keeping. Maybe they all deserve a separate designation.
It's true that the number of starts isn't a great measuring stick for a player's success but it's definitely better to have a third round pick ending up playing ibstead of sitting on the bench.
He is the Packers all time leading tackler and they Packers had some pretty good defenders I'd say.
Hawk didn't make enough impact plays though and had most of his tackles after opponents gained too many yards.