This is our ceiling!

Heyjoe4

Cheesehead
Joined
Apr 30, 2018
Messages
7,794
Reaction score
2,520
With the limited number of bodies allowed by the league it is difficult to have adequate depth at every position. Should Gute have signed another guard when Morgan went down? With 20/20 hindsight yes, but Gute may have had other areas to address too so rolled the dice.
Good point. And I'm sure the rookie was on the 53 because the coaches thought he could perform. The three holding penalties were probably due to nerves, but penalties nonetheless. And all areas can't be addresses. It is a numbers game.
 

Heyjoe4

Cheesehead
Joined
Apr 30, 2018
Messages
7,794
Reaction score
2,520
Let's be real about this. Unless some offensive lineman is an obvious flop in practice, the team really doesn't know until you put someone into a game. They didn't have many opportunities because our OL had great health this season. So it got down to the playoffs and we saw what we have for depth. I'll also not judge these guys for flopping in a road playoff game against a great DL.

As they always say, losing is just an opportunity to grow.
Yeah he hadn't played all season and so I'm sure nerves played a part. He was on the 53 for a reason. But a road playoff game against an excellent opponent would make any rookie edgy.

The OL really did stay healthy all season, a remarkable achievement. I'm still interested to see where Morgan fits in. Walker and Tom are solid at T. There was some talk about moving Tom to C. Maybe Morgan goes to RT?
 

Dantés

Gute Loot
Joined
Jan 21, 2017
Messages
12,128
Reaction score
3,048
This is it. Perennial playoff team that rarely goes the distance. Not being a entitled fan here, but just a realistic one. I'm still happy at where we are now (looking at you Bears), but it's time we awaken to reality.

- MLF has hit his his max capability and change needs to start with him. Maybe let the OC help with play calling, while he can look at some meta stuff like clock management, training against penalties etc. We have been mostly stagnant with just passing glimpses of brilliance making things more glitzy that they actually are. How can one be so strategic and blind at the same time!

- Gute's (and Ted's) team building is good to keep us here. We may need to rely on individual brilliance to take us further. But that's it. We are successful, but rarely dominate (looking at you, Lions). Overachievers, but never stars.

I really can't fault anyone as they have done their best. And here we are!

I am extremely disappointed by the outcome of this season.

However, it is crazy to say that the youngest team in the entire league has reached its ceiling.
 

shockerx

Cheesehead
Joined
Oct 11, 2010
Messages
354
Reaction score
138
Yeah he hadn't played all season and so I'm sure nerves played a part. He was on the 53 for a reason. But a road playoff game against an excellent opponent would make any rookie edgy.

The OL really did stay healthy all season, a remarkable achievement. I'm still interested to see where Morgan fits in. Walker and Tom are solid at T. There was some talk about moving Tom to C. Maybe Morgan goes to RT?
My big worry is Morgan's shoulder injury...it never seem to get better. There nothing worse than OL with chronic shoulder issues. Shoulders are complex and i think many guys become gun shy after repair, just ask JA, he never returned to what he was pre injury.
 

Heyjoe4

Cheesehead
Joined
Apr 30, 2018
Messages
7,794
Reaction score
2,520
My big worry is Morgan's shoulder injury...it never seem to get better. There nothing worse than OL with chronic shoulder issues. Shoulders are complex and i think many guys become gun shy after repair, just ask JA, he never returned to what he was pre injury.
Yeah the shoulder can be a chronic, troublesome injury. There are a lot of moving parts, and surgery to fix problems can have iffy outcomes. It's usually a rotator cuff tear that never seems to get fixed.

Well I hope Morgan can get well and be a contributor next year. To Dantes' point, it's crazy to say the NFL's youngest team has reached a ceiling. Changes are required in the offseason, just like every year.

My biggest wish for next year is that, for whatever reason(s), Love is able to play with confidence and aggression. He had that fire last season and maybe the early injuries set him back. Like the rest of the team, they should take some vacation and come back ready to play better.
 

Half Empty

Cheesehead
Joined
Oct 29, 2014
Messages
4,596
Reaction score
691
They have reached their peak because MLF & BG hitched their wagon to Love.

Now, going into year six of Love's career, Love still has wonky mechanics, inexplicably isn't a great runner when the need arises, can't 'dance' in the pocket well, is inaccurate with an extremely low completion % and throws INT's in big games (which is what he showed at Utah St.)

Clements & MLF deserve credit for getting Love way beyond where I thought possible, but, this is it, he's maxed out.

Fans keep comparing him to Favre/Rodgers, but, that is laughable. True comparison is Cousins, Mayfield, Cutler, Darnold, etc., guys that put up respectable regular seasons and get hot occasionally, but, will break your heart in the playoffs.

MLF & BG were high fiving when they drafted Love. They made their bed that day, and a SB is something they can only dream about now.
So, you're right back to comparing him to Favre and Rodgers?
 

shockerx

Cheesehead
Joined
Oct 11, 2010
Messages
354
Reaction score
138
Yeah the shoulder can be a chronic, troublesome injury. There are a lot of moving parts, and surgery to fix problems can have iffy outcomes. It's usually a rotator cuff tear that never seems to get fixed.

Well I hope Morgan can get well and be a contributor next year. To Dantes' point, it's crazy to say the NFL's youngest team has reached a ceiling. Changes are required in the offseason, just like every year.

My biggest wish for next year is that, for whatever reason(s), Love is able to play with confidence and aggression. He had that fire last season and maybe the early injuries set him back. Like the rest of the team, they should take some vacation and come back ready to play better.
My biggest fear with Love is that he has 5 years in the system surrounded by pro QB coaching and a hall of fame QB to learn from. I just feel he lacks the intangibles..the Championship DNA..i cant really describe it but you know when you see it. guys remaining have it... Mahomes Jackson Allen Stafford Goff
 

milani

Cheesehead
Joined
Jun 11, 2012
Messages
5,351
Reaction score
2,253
Good point. I can't recall the name of a single KC WR, and yet here they are again at 15-2 with a 1 seed. And it comes down to coaching and consistency. Andy Reid is the best. I'd rather see the Bills in the SB. I won't be surprised at all if it's the Chiefs.
What really showed the prowess of that KC coaching staff was not just the SB win. But they had to go into Buffalo and Baltimore and beat those teams on the road back to back to get there. What Packer team could ever do that?
 

Scotland Yard

What the hell is going on around here!
Joined
Dec 19, 2011
Messages
175
Reaction score
48
So, you're right back to comparing him to Favre and Rodgers?
O.K., so I should have written "will always break your heart in the playoffs."

Happy now?

Point is, Love is Green Bay's version of Jay Cutler, nothing more.
 

Firethorn1001

Cheesehead
Joined
Dec 20, 2015
Messages
1,983
Reaction score
1,516
People can gnash their teeth all they want, but with his dead cap number, tied to him for at least 2 years probably 3. Earliest out is 2027 and even that would be a $31M dead cap hit.
 

McKnowledge

Cheesehead
Joined
Dec 29, 2015
Messages
1,326
Reaction score
279
This entire organization and fan base needs to seriously adjust to the modern NFL.

Billions of dollars are generated from this league and the bottom line is success.

Winning is attributed to that success, and Green Bay is a winning organization.

But if I'm not mistaken Green Bay is Titletown, so where's the title. What is the standard?

Is it division? playoffs? NFC Championship? Super Bowl appearance? Winning championships?

What is the vision for this franchise? What's the endgame?

As a fan, I want to see a dynasty. I want to see greatness. I'm spoiled. We're spoiled.

Back-to-back HOF quarterbacks for 30 years.

Great players. Elite players.

The standard should be winning the Super Bowl, every year, and everyone pulling in that one direction, sharing the same vision.

However, if the standard is just making the playoffs and "going from there", then I'll adjust my expectations.

The standard determines how a team is constructed.

Championship teams establish a culture and maintain it and it begins with its core players.

The Patriots under Brady/Belichick and Chiefs under Mahomes/Reid are proven examples of identifying the cornerstones of their team and building around that.

Who are truly the cornerstone players on the Packers?
 

gopkrs

Cheesehead
Joined
May 12, 2014
Messages
5,903
Reaction score
1,571
This entire organization and fan base needs to seriously adjust to the modern NFL.

Billions of dollars are generated from this league and the bottom line is success.

Winning is attributed to that success, and Green Bay is a winning organization.

But if I'm not mistaken Green Bay is Titletown, so where's the title. What is the standard?

Is it division? playoffs? NFC Championship? Super Bowl appearance? Winning championships?

What is the vision for this franchise? What's the endgame?

As a fan, I want to see a dynasty. I want to see greatness. I'm spoiled. We're spoiled.

Back-to-back HOF quarterbacks for 30 years.

Great players. Elite players.

The standard should be winning the Super Bowl, every year, and everyone pulling in that one direction, sharing the same vision.

However, if the standard is just making the playoffs and "going from there", then I'll adjust my expectations.

The standard determines how a team is constructed.

Championship teams establish a culture and maintain it and it begins with its core players.

The Patriots under Brady/Belichick and Chiefs under Mahomes/Reid are proven examples of identifying the cornerstones of their team and building around that.

Who are truly the cornerstone players on the Packers?
A bit of luck involved too. Green Bay became Titletown because of winning all those titles in the 60s. There were a bunch of great players but anyone would be hard pressed not to acknowledge that Lombardi was truly The guy responsible. Kind of lucky to have had him. We should have won a couple more since then than we have. But looking to win a few more soon. I don't believe we are trying anything other than win it all. I guess when we do that; we'll all agree we did it right.
 
Top