First of all, I am not a Big Ben fan at all, but my personal dislike for the guy stems from all of his reported actions off the field. Maybe Big Ben is a big part of the problem in Pittsburgh, but that still doesn't absolve AB from his actions. If he is having a beef with Ben, have it out, don't quit practice and not show up the rest of the week and then expect to play on Sunday and be outraged when you don't. That isn't taking his frustrations out on Ben, its taking them out on his teammates.
I hesitate to even bring this up again, because I know you are a big AR supporter, which I am too, but I also recognize the fact that he likes things done his way. You really don't see how that could be a problem with AB?
I'm aware of that possibility, but what you fail to realize or what I don't think you seem to understand is how enabled he was in that locker room back in Pittsburgh. Hence one of the reasons as to why it was toxic. This is why I constantly brought up locker rooms such as ours and New England. Do you HONESTLY believe he'll act the same way he did in Pittsburgh? Personally based off what I've stated previously, I highly doubt it. He may have a temper and whatnot but I doubt he'd be able to get away with the stuff he did in Pittsburgh, because 1. If we're as good of an organization as we believe, we won't enable that kind of behavior. New England sure as hell wouldn't, hence why I often mention them because of how strong of an organization they are from the top going down.
A team player is one that doesn't put himself first. He is reliable, gives his all and communicates well with not just his coaches, but his teammates.
You might want to clean your ears out if it sounds to you like I said that people can't change. I simply said that given the cost of obtaining and paying Brown, his change wouldn't be something I would risk.
Chris Carter issues were with alcohol and drug abuse, including large amounts of ecstasy, cocaine and marijuana. Once he was able to rid those personal demons, he became a much better player. He was also a waiver pickup by the Vikings and cost them $225K.
Enlighten me on how Randy Moss and Antonio Brown are similar situations?
Apples to Apples is always a better way to go when discussing things. Maybe use Dez Bryant to try and argue your point?
I see Brown being capable of fitting those criterias simply for the fact that we won't enable that kind of behavior he did in Pittsburgh, and playing with a generational talent like Rodgers who makes everybody look better will help him in regards to making him look better. Yes again I'm aware of what he did in regards to missing practice and whatnot, but again that's failure on the organization as you've enabled him to where he felt he could pull that stunt.
As for me cleaning my ears out, tell you what (and I say this playfully) I'll do that when you be more clear deal?
To me personally I think based off his skillset, and how hard of a worker he is, that detracts from his personality issues, as I'm more focused on what he can do on the field. And every time he's gone on the field, he's never cheated you on effort.
As for Chris Carter, all that stuff you mentioned certainly doesn't seem to fit your "team player" definition now does it? And Chris has said constantly that he needed to leave Philly because if he had stayed there he probably wouldn't have made it. Going to Minnesota changed him to become a better player as well as a better man.
And you keep bringing up the cost of him, in which time and time I've said over and over if it's regarding the COST then I'd understand.
As for Randy Moss and Antonio Brown, you want me to do a quick comparison of the two? Fine.
-Arguably the best WR's in their skill position at the time. Top 5 in their respective era.
-Flamboyant/Show offy personalities (Randy Moss Moon/AB Twerking)
-Occasional hot heads that disrupted the locker rooms
- Questionable decisions (Randy Moss "I play when I want to play/AB missing practice)
-Mouth back to teammates and coaching staff
- Bonafide playmakers on the field.
I think you see my point. But you saw how Moss matured over time especially with his time with The Patriots. Perhaps the same could happen with Brown. As for Dez, I feel he's largely misunderstood personally due to how people misinterpret his passion on the field for a distraction, when the truth was, he wasn't the issue. But that's another time.
The Packers have enough on their plate with a new coaching staff and all of the sh*t that has been flying around about Rodgers and whatever his part in a bad 2018 season actually was or wasn't. I seriously don't think they need to take on the risk or potential distraction of having a player like AB thrown into the mix. Sure, he could come to Green Bay, play great, be a great teammate and all is well. However, I can also see the complete opposite happening, which ends up costing the Packers a pick or 2, the cap hit of whatever new contract he requires to play for and even worse, a new young head coach wondering how the season spun out so fast.
Now see, THAT I can understand. The cap hit being an issue, and the new coaching changes, and whatnot. But again that's why he's getting paid that money. That comes with the territory of being a coach. You can either fold to pressure or you can shine bright like a diamond. I'm gonna use a quote from Dr. Light (Video game character from the Megaman/Megaman X series) when he created Megaman X, in regards to Antonio Brown. Bear with me alright?
"Brown (X in the game) possess great risks, but as well as great possibilities. I can only hope for the best."
We'll see how it goes, but in any case though I appreciate your thoughts buddy. And again personally I'd prefer Odell over Brown. I'm just playing devil's advocate.