Do you not recall Gronk going on WWE four months after back surgery in 2017? There were a LOT of questions about his commitment after that. And how am I only mentioning players that fit my narrative? I'm mentioning players that did things that most fans thought were selfish or not good for the team. Do you have any players I missed that would weaken my argument or are you just annoyed I brought up good examples?
And please, give me some examples of Belichick alienating great players. But you can't just say "Bill doesn't have a magical touch" without actually sitting your statement when there's plenty of evidence that he's actually pretty good at working with diva players.
Gronk is not a good example. Its amazing that you think a guy like Gronk who just liked to party is somehow comparable to AB. It's actually kinda funny you think it is.
Revis is a bad example also. He was in NE for ONE year and the knock on him was solely based on wanting money and being a hired gun. He was never a head case. The question regarding him was solely is it worth the price tag for a rental of a CB
Moss isnt even a good example of BB letting players do their own thing. On the contrary bringing him up actually works AGAINST you're argument. The fact that you think bringing Moss up is a point in your favor shows a complete lack of understanding of how that situation ended.
The fact you think these are good examples comparable to AB is laughable. The only "possibly" good one is Moss and BB cut him loose the moment he stopped towing the company line
Now as far as leaving off the problem children that didnt turn out. Are you kidding me?
Forgot about Haynesworth have we?
Very impressive "forgetting" about Hernandez..... Like that epic levels
While Gordon (a player who you somehow neglected to mention even though hes the most recent example of a roll of the dice) "might" still work out but it should be noted hes just getting back from yet ANOTHER suspension. (also his knock isnt that hes a nutjob. Its that he likes to smoke weed)
I'll leave off the likes of Chad Johnson and a few others as those are players that were on their last legs.
The "BB is great at these reclamation projects" is a narrative that's lived for years based almost solely on Moss and Corey Dillon. (one who got cut for stepping out of line and one who was a "problem" simply because he wanted out of Cincinnati that was an even bigger dumpster fire then they are now after spending years there)
BB takes alot of swings at the plate with these types of players. His big strength with these types of guys is he cuts bait EXTREMELY quickly when they dont follow his lead. Not that he let's them do their own thing