Alright, friends... gather around while old Dantés gets something off his chest.
So Desmond King has been regarded for a few years as an excellent defensive back. This is due completely and solely to PFF putting big grades on him. I'm not saying he is or isn't good in reality; I don't know that. But the fact that he's widely
regarded as being good is all PFF. And that's fine-- they could be right. This is not an anti PFF take; they do a fine job.
But here is King's history: was drafted in the 5th round and in the last year he's been traded for a 6th, allowed to walk by the acquiring team, and then signed to one of the worst teams in the league for a very modest salary.
So yesterday, Peter Bukowski tweeted this:
Why does the NFL just not like Desmond King? Dude is legit good yet he’s been traded for peanuts and signed for some other kind of peanuts.
So here's the thing-- I have never in my life sat down and intentionally watched Desmond King play pro football. And here's something else-- neither has Peter Bukowski.
His assertion that "Dude is legit good" is obviously based solely on PFF giving him big grades. Because virtually no one is carefully studying players on teams that they don't cover, and even if he was, he wouldn't really know the finer points of what he's looking at (and neither would I or most fans).
And so this is what irks me. Basically the entirety of the NFL has told us in one way or another (by passing on him in the draft, not paying more than a late rounder to acquire him, good teams not being interested, signing a one year deal for like 3M or whatever) that they do not think much of this guy as a player. And then on the other side, you've got a player analysis website that loves him. And so Twitter Bros throw out takes that accept the PFF grade as gospel and don't even stop to consider that maybe the league might be right.
If this is you-- stop it. PFF is not the problem. People who think that PFF gives the final word/answer on everything are the problem. Don't be that guy.
Thank you for your time. Have a wonderful day.