I think he's better than Patrick Mahomes. He may look more athletic at the moment being 12 years younger and with a lot less miles but he also has had a lot of help in looking good. Not saying he's not, because he is, but he's been able to flip a ball out at any level on a broken type play and has had legitimate take it to the house every time players to flip it too. It helps. Rodgers has had some good passing targets over the years, don't get me wrong, but i don't think many of them come close to the natural big play ability that mahomes has been throwing too at their respective positions.
There's going to come a time when being the better QB is going to have to carry him, then we'll see. more athletic? sure. Better? debatable.