Unless the organization is very confident that Love is "the guy" we need to do everything we can to keep Rodgers. We've been spoiled with elite QB play for 30 years now. The Dolphins are still looking for Marino's replacement. The Bears haven't had an elite QB since Sid Luckman. It's entirely possible that we won't find a franchise QB for decades.
And in today's game, winning a Super Bowl without a top QB is extremely difficult. Back in the day, you could cobble together a good defense, a good running game, and get by with an average QB. With the league being increasingly passing heavy, it's much more difficult.
Think about it this way. In the last 30 years, how many teams won the Super Bowl with a QB who is/will not be in the hall of fame? I can only think of four. Trent Dilfer with the 2000 Ravens; Brad Johnson with the 2002 Bucs; Joe Flacco with the 2012 Ravens; and Nick Foles with the 2017 Eagles. Dilfer and Johnson also had historically great defenses. So 26 out of the last 30 Super Bowls, the winning team had a hall of fame QB. Replacing Rodgers could be extremely difficult and send us back to the 70s and 80s of mediocre QB play and little winning.