While I get what you are saying, the difference between knowing he is a FHOF QB and knowing he isn't, is quite large contract and dollar wise. Right now I think the Packers, as well as Love feel he is trending towards the FHOF QB, more than he is headed to being JAG.
So one has to ask themselves, what does that do to a contract if he is signed today? Probably puts him in the $45M/year range. So let's say the Packers wait until Nov. to resign him and we have 3 possible scenarios at that time, what is his contract value at each scenario?
- Very Good season, looks legit and continues to impress.
- Struggling, doesn't look as good as he did in 2023.
- Season ending injury, availability in 2024 uncertain.
If we learned nothing else from Bahk and a few other players, what is the rush to enter into a new contract, when the player is already under contract? Sure, there is the chance Love says "FU guys, I'm going to just play out my 5th year deal and hit Free Agency and land the biggest contract ever in the NFL." If that happens, the Packers always have the Franchise tag, which buys them more time.
I get it, you want to keep your QB happy, but didn't we see how that worked out with Rodgers? Before the Packers handcuff their future to just 1 player again, I want to be really sure about his abilities.