Barclay was decent though. Came in, worked hard and played a lot for a couple years and played pretty well. He was never the same after his knee injury though. Spriggs just looked like he had the tools, but never put the tools to good use. Very inconsistent, could be decent and then would get beat so badly it was dangerous for the QB. How do you run an offense with someone on the field you don't know if he's going to hold up, or watch as someone runs by with a free shot at a qb? Never knowing if the guy needs so much help it limits everything you do, or if he's going to hold up and allow you to run the play you need? or get your QB blown up?
Barclay had a couple good seasons, Spriggs would give us the better part of a quarter or so before getting beaten badly. At least Barclay had a destroyed knee that limited his ability, Spriggs looked like a monster, but that never came out on the field.