Favorite Packer Player of All time?

[Cheese Headed Monster]

Despite the drama, mine will forever be Brett Favre. A bit cliche' but the truth.

 

[RRyder]

Reggie White pretty easily

 

[PackerFanLV]

Charles Woodson

 

[CaptainCanuck]

Brett Favre

 

[C-Lee]

AR12 and Charles Woodson

 

[Arod2gjdd]

BJ Rajii

 

[HardRightEdge]

I couldn't pick just one. Lets just say Favre would not be in my top 10.

 

[Cheese Headed Monster]

I couldn't pick just one. Lets just say Favre would not be in my top 10.

Hot take! To each their own!

 

[Cheese Headed Monster]

BJ Rajii

Remind me again what happened to him? Didn't he just say he didn't wanna play anymore or something?

 

[CaptainCanuck]

I couldn't pick just one. Lets just say Favre would not be in my top 10.

Reason?

 

[HardRightEdge]

Hot take! To each their own!

That goes without saying.

 

[Cheese Headed Monster]

Reason?

Incoming "he held the organization hostage with his retirement talk." Followed by "He went to a division rival just to rub it in the Packers faces." I am sorry but any player who starts that many consecutive games for a team will have my respect. Toughness is a lost skill in today's NFL.

 

[Arod2gjdd]

Remind me again what happened to him? Didn't he just say he didn't wanna play anymore or something?

Yep, was kind of a joke because Rodgers and Woodson are my all-time favorites and someone already said that, but big BJ did help us win a super bowl

 

[I asked LT to delete my acct]

Incoming "he held the organization hostage with his retirement talk." Followed by "He went to a division rival just to rub it in the Packers faces." I am sorry but any player who starts that many consecutive games for a team will have my respect. Toughness is a lost skill in today's NFL.

We have a WHOLE thread dedicated to Mr Favre, we don't need a prolonged discussion here thank you gentlemen

 

[Cheese Headed Monster]

We have a WHOLE thread dedicated to Mr Favre, we don't need a prolonged discussion here thank you gentlemen

Dont worry it wasn't gonna get that far!

 

[I asked LT to delete my acct]

Dont worry it wasn't gonna get that far!

Glad to know that. We've had enough of that argument. Welcome to the forum.

 

[Cheese Headed Monster]

Yep, was kind of a joke because Rodgers and Woodson are my all-time favorites and someone already said that, but big BJ did help us win a super bowl

Let me ask you this, So Aaron is your fav Packer (one of). Why? I'm being 100% genuine? I am interested to know peoples reasons behind that. Is it based on his purely on his skill? I would agree with you he is the most skilled QB (maybe player) we ever had. But I find him not very likeable. Please dont "X" me to hell for this but doesnt he come off a bit moody and Jay Cutler-y at times in terms of personality and attitude?

 

[I asked LT to delete my acct]

I always liked James Jones myself.

 

[Conso]

Despite the drama, mine will forever be Brett Favre. A bit cliche' but the truth.

While his contributions to the team during his career are obvious, his blatant spit-in-the-face still leaves a bad taste in my mouth. My vote goes to WR Sterling Sharpe, for those of you who didn’t get to see him play he was the Aaron Rodgers or Brett Favre before them both. While not as impactful as a QB can be, he basically carried the team until his career ending injury. Him and Donald Driver together were as deadly a 1-2 punch as Jerry Rice and his #2 (forgot his name lol) we just didn’t have squat for QBs until we traded for Favre.

 

[swhitset]

Let me ask you this, So Aaron is your fav Packer (one of). Why? I'm being 100% genuine? I am interested to know peoples reasons behind that. Is it based on his purely on his skill? I would agree with you he is the most skilled QB (maybe player) we ever had. But I find him not very likeable. Please dont "X" me to hell for this but doesnt he come off a bit moody and Jay Cutler-y at times in terms of personality and attitude?

You won’t get a red x from me on that one. I will be sorry when Aaron ultimately retires. He is one of the best ever and always gives the Packers a chance to win. I don’t personally dislike him, but yes at times his attitude does rub me the wrong way.

 

[Cheese Headed Monster]

While his contributions to the team during his career are obvious, his blatant spit-in-the-face still leaves a bad taste in my mouth. My vote goes to WR Sterling Sharpe, for those of you who didn’t get to see him play he was the Aaron Rodgers or Brett Favre before them both. While not as impactful as a QB can be, he basically carried the team until his career ending injury. Him and Donald Driver together were as deadly a 1-2 punch as Jerry Rice and his #2 (forgot his name lol) we just didn’t have squat for QBs until we traded for Favre.

I was waiting for Sharpe to show up. Watched some highlights with him recently. Dude was solid

 

[Cheese Headed Monster]

I always liked James Jones myself.

I loved watching him play. Even with his sleeveless hoodie!

 

[Conso]

Let me ask you this, So Aaron is your fav Packer (one of). Why? I'm being 100% genuine? I am interested to know peoples reasons behind that. Is it based on his purely on his skill? I would agree with you he is the most skilled QB (maybe player) we ever had. But I find him not very likeable. Please dont "X" me to hell for this but doesnt he come off a bit moody and Jay Cutler-y at times in terms of personality and attitude?

I think a lot of the reason is because he carries the team, half the time all alone. I agree with you that Aaron’s personality has gotten worse over the years, more egotistical, more “aggressively opinionated” what have you. It’s the fact that without Aaron we would have a significantly worse performing team since Favre left, he literally carries the team either from bad coaching staff choices or a now former GM who ran the team into the ground.

 

[Conso]

I was waiting for Sharpe to show up. Watched some highlights with him recently. Dude was solid

He was our “Megatron”, our Rice, just as good as them too.

 

[swhitset]

I think a lot of the reason is because he carries the team, half the time all alone. I agree with you that Aaron’s personality has gotten worse over the years, more egotistical, more “aggressively opinionated” what have you. It’s the fact that without Aaron we would have a significantly worse performing team since Favre left, he literally carries the team either from bad coaching staff choices or a now former GM who ran the team into the ground.

That former GM drafted him and built a Super bowl winning team. Yes, I think it was time for him to leave... but he deserves more respect than your post suggests.