Back in my early 20s, a buddy had an old pontoon on a remote lake. On a rainy day, we added some 2x4 posts and a giant tarp. We set out on the lake with a keg of beer and 6 guys playing poker. The rule was that if you got knocked out of the game (out of money - we played with quarters), you could fish your way back into the game. Once you caught a fish, you had to slap someone in the face with it. That person then had to give you $1 in quarters out of their winnings to stake you back into the game.
We ran ashore many times that day. Fun times, but I don't remember any carp. It was mostly sun fish and an occasional hammer handle.