State of our former QB, Aaron Rodgers

Magooch

Cheesehead
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Messages
1,269
Reaction score
1,231
To be fair, I would also propose it is probably not a coincidence that the "talking heads" in the media seem to find more drama with a guy who tends to disparage the media and pretty much only gives exclusive access to McAfee (who himself is not exactly a darling of the "legacy media" either)....
 

Heyjoe4

Cheesehead
Joined
Apr 30, 2018
Messages
8,306
Reaction score
2,731
maybe this isn’t directed at your post specifically but more thought provoking. I know you’re just having fun I do that also. I know Aaron is drama. But for whatever reason I have walk a mile in a man’s shoes type attitude about him. For those that still believe $ solves problems, Solomon said it’s like chasing the wind. He’s got problems like everyone else and so I guess he probably does not deserve sympathy, but I give him some compassion also. At his root I think he’s actually a really good person or at least I see something in him that grasping for goodness. He’s a little craze in the surface but might be the last man to stay in your bunker with you type also.

It is what it is. He’s not an elite QB anymore imo. I think he’s certainly good enough to have a bounce back season still and put himself in that top 6 or top 8 category. That = if the Defense and Teams and Coaching all align a pretty formidable opponent. Last time he won a SB we had a top Defense. He needs to be on a team like Brady had with some O weapons and a Top Defense. Steelers or Vikings are his best shot of 3 outside possibilities in 2025 and the door is closing on 2 of them. Pittsburgh seems to be ok courting him. I think Rodgers likes to play hard to get. Who Does not want to be desired? I just see him as a Steeler and he could be a very good fit for his last season or two.
Rodgers wanting a red-carpet welcome, with cherubs throwing rose petals in his path as he enters the room, is a joke. The ayahuasca-fried his brain. This isn't a diss of his career (overall) and his future HOF induction. But clearly Rodgers sees himself as something he is not.

Maybe the Jets could have or should have handled his dismissal via phone or Zoom. But Rodgers would then accuse the Jets of not being brave enough to meet him face-to-face. Rodgers always finds someone to take responsibility for something, as long as it's not him. I mean geez the Jets even required that he pay for his flight. Poor baby.
 
Last edited:

Pokerbrat2000

Opinions are like A-holes, we all have one.
Joined
Oct 30, 2012
Messages
34,636
Reaction score
9,555
Location
Madison, WI
To be fair, I would also propose it is probably not a coincidence that the "talking heads" in the media seem to find more drama with a guy who tends to disparage the media and pretty much only gives exclusive access to McAfee (who himself is not exactly a darling of the "legacy media" either)....

Sounds a lot like a Political QB that I read about daily, every 30 minutes it seems. ;)

I guess while I agree with you about the media pumping the drama more than they would with say a 3rd string LB, that is the price you pay for being a star in the NFL. If you want to be under the spot light for all the Hall of Fame Moments, don't give them anything to keep that spotlight on off the field. Rodgers pretends to hate the spotlight, but his words/actions tells me that he actually enjoys all the attention.

One question for you; "Besides his family stuff, where was all this drama prior to 2020?"
 

Magooch

Cheesehead
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Messages
1,269
Reaction score
1,231
Sounds a lot like a Political QB that I read about daily, every 30 minutes it seems. ;)

I guess while I agree with you about the media pumping the drama more than they would with say a 3rd string LB, that is the price you pay for being a star in the NFL. If you want to be under the spot light for all the Hall of Fame Moments, don't give them anything to keep that spotlight on off the field. Rodgers pretends to hate the spotlight, but his words/actions tells me that he actually enjoys all the attention.

What I mean isn't that I don't think it really comes just with being a star. There are plenty of star players who you almost never hear talked about (and plenty of them are difficult, hold controversial beliefs, etc). Maybe it's chicken vs egg but I'm pretty confident that (star or not) if Rodgers hadn't seemingly made it a point to disparage the "legacy" sports media, there'd probably be 75% less chatter about him, regardless of everything else. Like I said, I think he does have a tendency to keep things going (in that he feels like a "get the last word in" type of guy) but I also think it's a case where a lot of the "news" about Rodgers is only news...because the people who make the news are telling us it's important news :p

One question for you; "Besides his family stuff, where was all this drama prior to 2020?"
That's kind of what I mean though. I don't think Rodgers' personality radically changed at this point and I don't think he reinvented his beliefs at this time BUT it is around the time that Rodgers started appearing on McAfee more and started his "campaign" of criticisms directed at much of the rest of sports media.

And I don't want to get too into the weeds about it but I suspect for many much of the "drama" can all stem back to his "immunized" comments (which for the record I found to be immature, boneheaded, and deliberately misleading, although I think a simple "no comment" should have been a perfectly acceptable answer without inviting further prying/questioning) and I have a hunch there are many media types who are never going to forgive or forget him committing that unpardonable sin...but again I think that will probably take the conversation a messy direction for many :D
 

Pokerbrat2000

Opinions are like A-holes, we all have one.
Joined
Oct 30, 2012
Messages
34,636
Reaction score
9,555
Location
Madison, WI
I suspect for many much of the "drama" can all stem back to his "immunized" comments (which for the record I found to be immature, boneheaded, and deliberately misleading, although I think a simple "no comment" should have been a perfectly acceptable answer without inviting further prying/questioning) and I have a hunch there are many media types who are never going to forgive or forget him committing that unpardonable sin...but again I think that will probably take the conversation a messy direction for many :D

I actually thought Rodgers was a different guy after Jordan Love was drafted. It went downhill from there. The whole "I've been immunized" comment just added a lot of outside (non-NFL) fuel to the fire.
 
OP
OP
OldSchool101
Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Messages
17,157
Reaction score
7,800
If the Rodgers decision is being held up by either side, based on who they come out of the draft with, something is messed up. Even if the Steelers get Sanders, they would be crazy to start him year 1. Rodgers is a temporary 1-2 year plug and play vet, nothing more, nothing less.

I still think Rodgers wants to play for the Vikings and is hoping that either JJ McCarthy gets hit by a bus or he looks unready to be the starter. Perfect place for Rodgers to end his career. Indoors for 11 of 17 games, gets to play the Packers twice and a team that is coming off of a 14-3 record.
Oh I agree. Rodgers best landing spot would’ve been the Vikes.
For me, Rodgers passive aggressive style of trying to be the smartest guy in the room/organization is what would make him a "Hard Pass" for me. He tried to change his spots with the Jets, yet in the end, there he was, the passive aggressive guy who tried to blame the Jets organization for everything wrong. Yup, maybe that is true, but they just paid you a ton of money, STFU and move on.
yeah, but would it be a hard deal to pass for $25 million like a 50,000,00 2year deal
 
Last edited:

Thirteen Below

Cheesehead
Joined
Jan 15, 2022
Messages
1,380
Reaction score
1,118
If the Rodgers decision is being held up by either side, based on who they come out of the draft with, something is messed up. Even if the Steelers get Sanders, they would be crazy to start him year 1. Rodgers is a temporary 1-2 year plug and play vet, nothing more, nothing less.

I still think Rodgers wants to play for the Vikings and is hoping that either JJ McCarthy gets hit by a bus or he looks unready to be the starter. Perfect place for Rodgers to end his career. Indoors for 11 of 17 games, gets to play the Packers twice and a team that is coming off of a 14-3 record.
Dude, I believe you completely nailed it. Every word of it.
 

Thirteen Below

Cheesehead
Joined
Jan 15, 2022
Messages
1,380
Reaction score
1,118
But you seem to care
We are deeply caring people.



I actually thought Rodgers was a different guy after Jordan Love was drafted. It went downhill from there. The whole "I've been immunized" comment just added a lot of outside (non-NFL) fuel to the fire.
I actually deep-dove into this a month or two ago, and found a lot of reporting indicating that whatever bug he had up his *** in 2020 had actually first started crawling in there in 2018. A lot of that reporting was supported by quote from Rodgers himself. I used my AI app to collate all the details, and will paste the whole thing here (it's not copyrighted material)

This is long, so fair warning... Half Empty? You're gonna wanna scroll past it, and maybe a few others will too. :p

But it is pretty detailed and thorough, for those who are interested in the whole story; evidently Rodgers was a lot grumpier for the last several years than any of us could have guessed....

For those who don't use AI yet, the way it works is that it crawls the entire internet and scrapes every detail it can find on the topic (which in this case was, "what events and developments began happening in green bay in 2018 that first began to alienate aaron rodgers and cause friction and tension between him and the packer organization"), and then organizes and summarizes it. It's usually amazingly accurate and comprehensive, and in this case, it agrees with everything I found myself with google a month or two back.

Except it took 20 seconds instead of 45 minutes, and organized it better than i could have.

And again, most of this is supported by interviews with Rodgers in the intervening years; the AI app provides links to every source - they just don't show up when I copy and paste.



Several key events and developments in 2018 began to alienate Aaron Rodgers and cause significant friction between him and the Green Bay Packers organization:


1. Dismissal of Trusted Allies

  • The Packers fired quarterbacks coach Alex Van Pelt in January 2018, a move that Rodgers publicly criticized, expressing disappointment at not being consulted. Van Pelt was a confidant to Rodgers, and his ouster was seen as a scapegoating for the offense’s struggles236.
  • Rodgers was also upset by the release of wide receiver Jordy Nelson, his close friend and favorite target, in the spring of 2018. This decision, made without Rodgers’ input, further strained his trust in the organization’s leadership26.
2. Frustration with Offensive Philosophy and Play-Calling

  • Throughout the 2018 season, Rodgers grew increasingly frustrated with head coach Mike McCarthy’s offensive scheme, which he felt was stale and predictable. Despite public claims of a “scrub-brush approach” to overhaul the offense, McCarthy retained play-calling duties and brought back Joe Philbin as offensive coordinator, signaling little real change26.
  • Rodgers began openly criticizing the game plans and play-calling in media appearances, including postgame comments after a win over Buffalo in Week 4, where he called the offense “as bad as we’ve played... in a long time”136.
  • Reports and player accounts revealed that Rodgers frequently overruled McCarthy’s play calls in the huddle, audibling to his own plays at an unprecedented rate—estimated at up to one-third or even 63% of called plays. This act of rebellion was a clear sign of deteriorating trust and communication457.
3. Breakdown in Coach-Quarterback Relationship

  • The relationship between Rodgers and McCarthy, already complicated by long-standing personal and professional differences, deteriorated into a visible power struggle. Both men wanted credit for the offense’s success and disagreed on philosophy, personnel usage, and play selection157.
  • Rodgers’ lack of trust in McCarthy extended to his handling of younger receivers, as he reportedly froze out those who didn’t meet his expectations, further undermining the coaching staff’s authority7.
  • The dynamic became so toxic that McCarthy had effectively lost control of the team by late 2018, culminating in his firing after a home loss to the 2-9 Arizona Cardinals57.
4. General Organizational Disconnect

  • Rodgers’ growing desire for input on personnel and strategic decisions was not matched by the front office’s actions. The lack of communication and inclusion on major moves (such as staff changes and player releases) left Rodgers feeling marginalized and undervalued267.
  • Despite being made the highest-paid player in NFL history before the season, Rodgers’ relationship with the organization continued to sour due to these unresolved issues67.

So, that's 2018.

There were more incidents of that nature in 2018 that AI did not find, such as a time when McCarthy sent in a play to the huddle, and Rodgers paused a moment, said "**** that ****", and called a different play - reported by Mercedes Lewis (already a 13-year vet), who said he'd never quite seen a quarterback do that before, and initially assumed it must be a crazy joke. But he and other receivers reported that this was frequent, that some games Rodgers changed more than half the plays that came in from the sideline, and didn't care what anyone thought about it.

There was more history n 2019 and 20, regarding receiver Jake Kumerow, upon whom Rodgers apparently had developed something of a man crush. In an interview, Rodgers described Kumerow as a "fantastic, steady player" and a "roster lock," emphasizing his reliability and value to the team. This was on the evening of Friday, September 4, 2020.

Early the morning of September 5, 2019, Green Bay cut Kumerow.

This was was described by multiple sources as a "significant blow to Rodgers’ relationship with the organization", with NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport calling it "a little bit of a death knell in the relationship" and reporting that it "drove Rodgers nuts".

A few months later, some reporters asked Aaron what he thought about some young player, and he said something like "I'm not going to comment on personnel; last time I did that the guy got cut the next morning." Rodgers apparently viewed it as a personal bop on the beak. Whether or not that was justified, who knows, because.... well... Rodgers.

Additionally, when McCarthy was finally voted off the island in 2019, Rodgers supposedly huffed and puffed because he was not personally consulted as to who they should bring in to replace McCarthy. There was reporting that he felt he should have been a part of that decision, even though he did think Lafleur was a good hire.

Rodgers also expressed a lot of frustration that the team was making major personnel moves without including him in the discussions....
“I’m talking about Charles Woodson, Jordy Nelson, Julius Peppers, Clay Matthews, Randall Cobb, James Jones, John Kuhn, Brett Goode, TJ Lang, Bryan Bulaga, Casey Hayward, Micah Hyde,” Rodgers said.

Rodgers said he wanted to use his position to be a recruiter for other players on the open market.

“Green Bay isn’t a huge vacation destination,” Rodgers said. “People are coming here to play with me, to play with our team and knowing that they can win a championship here. And the fact that I haven’t been used in those discussions was what I wanted to change moving forward.”


He said after that, nothing changed on that front. As they got into March, Rodgers told the Packers if he is not part of the future and they want to make the change, then “go ahead and do it.”


When the Packers hired head coach Matt LaFleur, Rodgers said he wasn’t consulted.



“I do love Matt, we have had a blast together and I am glad he is here, but it’s decisions like that have happened over and over and over again that make me realize that the organization looks at me and my job as just to play,” Rodgers said. “In my opinion, based on what I have accomplished in this league, the way I care about my teammates, the way I show up in the locker room, the way I lead, the way I conduct myself in the community, it should tie myself to a little bit more input.”


Other reporting suggests that he had a serious grudge against McCarthy ever since Day One, but whether that's true or not, who can say.


But even in the best of times—when confetti should've still been stuck to their clothing—one person who was then close to Rodgers remembers he would regularly call to vent that McCarthy didn't have a clue what he was doing. He'd tell him that McCarthy frequently called the wrong play. That he used the wrong personnel. That they were running plays that worked one out of 50 times in practice. That McCarthy was a buffoon he was constantly bailing out.
"Mike has a low football IQ, and that used to always bother Aaron," this source says. "He'd say Mike has one of the lowest IQs, if not the lowest IQ, of any coach he's ever had."



This is a point of view I've seen reporters hint at a lot over the years, but never express as directly as this article does. Why that is, I can't say. Maybe it's ********, all speculation, over the top. Maybe it has some validity, but still too much too far. Or maybe it just has some truth to it, but we'll never know how much at this point.

But whatever happened evidently started happening years before any of us saw it starting to happen. Which side is right, which side is wrong, I'm not gonna pick a side. I know Gutekunst has said that he wished he'd handled the whole situation differently, and I think I've seen Aaron say similar. Whatever is done is done, and we're all at where we are at.

But the narrative seems to indicate that it didn't begin to unravel the moment Jordan Love was drafted - for whatever reason or reasons, it had been building toward that flashpoint for several years, and if it hadn't been that then it would have been something else later. Cuz that's just where that train was heading.
 
Last edited:

Heyjoe4

Cheesehead
Joined
Apr 30, 2018
Messages
8,306
Reaction score
2,731
We are deeply caring people.




I actually deep-dove into this a month or two ago, and found a lot of reporting indicating that whatever bug he had up his *** in 2020 had actually first started crawling in there in 2018. A lot of that reporting was supported by quote from Rodgers himself. I used my AI app to collate all the details, and will paste the whole thing here (it's not copyrighted material)

This is long, so fair warning... Half Empty? You're gonna wanna scroll past it, and maybe a few others will too. :p

But it is pretty detailed and thorough, for those who are interested in the whole story; evidently Rodgers was a lot grumpier for the last several years than any of us could have guessed....

For those who don't use AI yet, the way it works is that it crawls the entire internet and scrapes every detail it can find on the topic (which in this case was, "what events and developments began happening in green bay in 2018 that first began to alienate aaron rodgers and cause friction and tension between him and the packer organization"), and then organizes and summarizes it. It's usually amazingly accurate and comprehensive, and in this case, it agrees with everything I found myself with google a month or two back.

Except it took 20 seconds instead of 45 minutes, and organized it better than i could have.

And again, most of this is supported by interviews with Rodgers in the intervening years; the AI app provides links to every source - they just don't show up when I copy and paste.





So, that's 2018.

There were more incidents of that nature in 2018 that AI did not find, such as a time when McCarthy sent in a play to the huddle, and Rodgers paused a moment, said "**** that ****", and called a different play - reported by Mercedes Lewis (already a 13-year vet), who said he'd never quite seen a quarterback do that before, and initially assumed it must be a crazy joke. But he and other receivers reported that this was frequent, that some games Rodgers changed more than half the plays that came in from the sideline, and didn't care what anyone thought about it.

There was more history n 2019 and 20, regarding receiver Jake Kumerow, upon whom Rodgers apparently had developed something of a man crush. In an interview, Rodgers described Kumerow as a "fantastic, steady player" and a "roster lock," emphasizing his reliability and value to the team. This was on the evening of Friday, September 4, 2020.

Early the morning of September 5, 2019, Green Bay cut Kumerow.

This was was described by multiple sources as a "significant blow to Rodgers’ relationship with the organization", with NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport calling it "a little bit of a death knell in the relationship" and reporting that it "drove Rodgers nuts".

A few months later, some reporters asked Aaron what he thought about some young player, and he said something like "I'm not going to comment on personnel; last time I did that the guy got cut the next morning." Rodgers apparently viewed it as a personal bop on the beak. Whether or not that was justified, who knows, because.... well... Rodgers.

Additionally, when McCarthy was finally voted off the island in 2019, Rodgers supposedly huffed and puffed because he was not personally consulted as to who they should bring in to replace McCarthy. There was reporting that he felt he should have been a part of that decision, even though he did think Lafleur was a good hire.

Rodgers also expressed a lot of frustration that the team was making major personnel moves without including him in the discussions....








Other reporting suggests that he had a serious grudge against McCarthy ever since Day One, but whether that's true or not, who can say.






This is a point of view I've seen reporters hint at a lot over the years, but never express as directly as this article does. Why that is, I can't say. Maybe it's ********, all speculation, over the top. Maybe it has some validity, but still too much too far. Or maybe it just has some truth to it, but we'll never know how much at this point.

But whatever happened evidently started happening years before any of us saw it starting to happen. Which side is right, which side is wrong, I'm not gonna pick a side. I know Gutekunst has said that he wished he'd handled the whole situation differently, and I think I've seen Aaron say similar. Whatever is done is done, and we're all at where we are at.

But the narrative seems to indicate that it didn't begin to unravel the moment Jordan Love was drafted - for whatever reason or reasons, it had been building toward that flashpoint for several years, and if it hadn't been that then it would have been something else later. Cuz that's just where that train was heading.
“In my opinion, based on what I have accomplished in this league, the way I care about my teammates, the way I show up in the locker room, the way I lead, the way I conduct myself in the community, it should tie myself to a little bit more input.”

Hi 13 and thanks for the research.

I highlighted this quote only to point out - if you're the only person who thinks you deserve a greater role (pick any industry, any job) or a promotion, or whatever, well that's a problem. Rodgers uses "I, my, myself" 8 times, in one sentence.

Have to feel bad for the guy when he seems to be delusional. He is gonna have no career opportunities once he finishes with football. He's too alienating to make for a good color broadcaster (he flunked his Jeopardy MC opportunity because he just isn't a likable guy).

All that money, all that fame, and a total inability to look inside, even just once in a while. He is easy to anger and unable to be self critical. I would not want a life like that.
 
Last edited:

Voyageur

Cheesehead
Joined
Nov 10, 2021
Messages
3,208
Reaction score
2,672
Who is Aaron Rodgers? He's not the same guy who played over a decade with the Packers. The guy everyone is talking about is an old Packer who is no longer there, who's trying to hang on to a life he's enjoyed for so long. His whole life has been around football, and he's clinging to it just like Tom Brady did, and so many players have in the past. It becomes embedded in their DNA. I understand that feeling deep inside. I remember play fast-pitch softball until I was 56 years old and had a stroke. After making substantial recovery, I tried for three years to return to the field to play.

Even after I got my legs back, and the majority of my coordination, I was 59 years old and working towards playing. I wanted it. I wanted it DESPERATELY!!!! I'd substituted slow and fast pitch softball into my life the day after I quit playing baseball. The day I realized that I could no longer hang in there with the new kids on the block. They were beginning to be better than me.

So, here I was. 59 years old. I went to a batting cage every day for over two months. I'd take at least 100 swings every day. Sometimes as many as 200. I built my arm strength up and worked hard. But my legs kept failing me. I'd moved from the outfield to 1st base when I was about 50. That was a blow. I'd already moved from centerfield to left field which hurt. I loved playing centerfield. It was my "kingdom" and nobody could outplay me. I could make those catches that make highlight reels. Then a guy 25 years younger, and faster, outplayed me and I ended up in left field. I also ended up moving from clean-up hitter to 5th or 6th in the lineup. I was still one of the top 3 hitters on the team as far as average, but I wasn't drilling as many over the fence or getting too many extra bases like I did when I was younger. I could see it in the stats, and I knew it, but I didn't want to accept it. At 59, hitting one to the wall but not over was a real chore. They ended up fly outs, not dingers, like they were in the past. The power was gone. In the end, I found myself as a "utility first baseman" for several games and realized that I was only there because of what I did in the past. They were being kind to let me stick around. It was gone. So, I retired from the game completely.

Even today, at 84, I can't bear to watch a softball game because it hurts knowing I can't do it like I did in the past. I avoid them.

Rodgers is nearing his "59." It happens to all athletes. If you've been there, you understand. You try to hang on because it's what you love and feel you do best.

If you feel anything for him, feel that he's like a horse trying to run one more race. Hanging on to be a winner. My favorite horse was a gelding named John Henry. He didn't arrive on the scene as a winner until he was long-in-the-tooth. He ran his heart out, and was an amazing horse. I kind of like to think of myself as having been a little bit like him when playing sports, but at a lesser level. I think guys like Favre, Brady, and Rodgers, all fit into that same mold. They all wanted to go out a winner just like John Henry.

But that's just my opinion, for what it's worth. After you read a little about John Henry, I think you'll see what I mean.

 

Pokerbrat2000

Opinions are like A-holes, we all have one.
Joined
Oct 30, 2012
Messages
34,636
Reaction score
9,555
Location
Madison, WI
We are deeply caring people.




I actually deep-dove into this a month or two ago, and found a lot of reporting indicating that whatever bug he had up his *** in 2020 had actually first started crawling in there in 2018. A lot of that reporting was supported by quote from Rodgers himself. I used my AI app to collate all the details, and will paste the whole thing here (it's not copyrighted material)

This is long, so fair warning... Half Empty? You're gonna wanna scroll past it, and maybe a few others will too. :p

But it is pretty detailed and thorough, for those who are interested in the whole story; evidently Rodgers was a lot grumpier for the last several years than any of us could have guessed....

For those who don't use AI yet, the way it works is that it crawls the entire internet and scrapes every detail it can find on the topic (which in this case was, "what events and developments began happening in green bay in 2018 that first began to alienate aaron rodgers and cause friction and tension between him and the packer organization"), and then organizes and summarizes it. It's usually amazingly accurate and comprehensive, and in this case, it agrees with everything I found myself with google a month or two back.

Except it took 20 seconds instead of 45 minutes, and organized it better than i could have.

And again, most of this is supported by interviews with Rodgers in the intervening years; the AI app provides links to every source - they just don't show up when I copy and paste.





So, that's 2018.

There were more incidents of that nature in 2018 that AI did not find, such as a time when McCarthy sent in a play to the huddle, and Rodgers paused a moment, said "**** that ****", and called a different play - reported by Mercedes Lewis (already a 13-year vet), who said he'd never quite seen a quarterback do that before, and initially assumed it must be a crazy joke. But he and other receivers reported that this was frequent, that some games Rodgers changed more than half the plays that came in from the sideline, and didn't care what anyone thought about it.

There was more history n 2019 and 20, regarding receiver Jake Kumerow, upon whom Rodgers apparently had developed something of a man crush. In an interview, Rodgers described Kumerow as a "fantastic, steady player" and a "roster lock," emphasizing his reliability and value to the team. This was on the evening of Friday, September 4, 2020.

Early the morning of September 5, 2019, Green Bay cut Kumerow.

This was was described by multiple sources as a "significant blow to Rodgers’ relationship with the organization", with NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport calling it "a little bit of a death knell in the relationship" and reporting that it "drove Rodgers nuts".

A few months later, some reporters asked Aaron what he thought about some young player, and he said something like "I'm not going to comment on personnel; last time I did that the guy got cut the next morning." Rodgers apparently viewed it as a personal bop on the beak. Whether or not that was justified, who knows, because.... well... Rodgers.

Additionally, when McCarthy was finally voted off the island in 2019, Rodgers supposedly huffed and puffed because he was not personally consulted as to who they should bring in to replace McCarthy. There was reporting that he felt he should have been a part of that decision, even though he did think Lafleur was a good hire.

Rodgers also expressed a lot of frustration that the team was making major personnel moves without including him in the discussions....








Other reporting suggests that he had a serious grudge against McCarthy ever since Day One, but whether that's true or not, who can say.






This is a point of view I've seen reporters hint at a lot over the years, but never express as directly as this article does. Why that is, I can't say. Maybe it's ********, all speculation, over the top. Maybe it has some validity, but still too much too far. Or maybe it just has some truth to it, but we'll never know how much at this point.

But whatever happened evidently started happening years before any of us saw it starting to happen. Which side is right, which side is wrong, I'm not gonna pick a side. I know Gutekunst has said that he wished he'd handled the whole situation differently, and I think I've seen Aaron say similar. Whatever is done is done, and we're all at where we are at.

But the narrative seems to indicate that it didn't begin to unravel the moment Jordan Love was drafted - for whatever reason or reasons, it had been building toward that flashpoint for several years, and if it hadn't been that then it would have been something else later. Cuz that's just where that train was heading.
Great post, thanks.

I think for many fans, myself included, we put up with or looked the other way, at the early negative Rodgers stuff. He had been a Packer since 2005 and we saw him as our FHOF QB, the best QB in the NFL and a guy that was loved by his teammates. "Who cares what his family says, Who cares what his Ex's say. Of course he is going to audible out of the head coaches play calls."

I do agree though, the head butting with McCarthy, as well as Rodgers unhappiness with some personnel decisions, were the bigger cracks in perfect the picture that most of us had painted of Rodgers. That started to change how some viewed Rodgers. Had Rodgers just been a rookie or average player, maybe nobody gives him a free pass at that time of all those things.

For me, the drafting of Love and how Rodgers reacted to it, was when the dark light started to really shine on Rodgers. Rodgers pretended to not be too upset about the pick, but his actions after that day said otherwise.
 

gopkrs

Cheesehead
Joined
May 12, 2014
Messages
6,120
Reaction score
1,668
We are deeply caring people.
I only checked this out because I was quoted. Iv'e take PokerBrat to heart and no longer look at this thread. I think it is all total BS and soap opera crap. And I don't have any hard feelings about ARod nor the way he goes about things. I was glad he was traded because he wasn't looking at the whole field and seemed to always be making faces at the receivers instead of just dealing with what he had and throwing to an open receiver imho. And also seemingly changing too many play calls at the line of scrimmage and taking too long to hike the ball. But all that is now over and I don't care about his situation. For the record though; I think he will play with the steelers. And I hope he has a good year.
 
Last edited:

Magooch

Cheesehead
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Messages
1,269
Reaction score
1,231
As I said before, it would seem that the Steelers are certainly aware of any and all of the "drama" (and I would have to venture to guess that they are in fact considerably MORE aware than any of us here are)...and they saw his play last season just like we did, too (again: with a greater degree of analysis/scrutiny than we are also privy to, either) and yet there is seemingly still at least some contingent who currently view Rodgers as their best option for the immediate future. And lest we forget, the Steelers are pretty consistently regarded as one of the best-ran franchises in the league...

Now like I said, maybe they are waiting it out and will draft someone tonight. But even setting aside the draft, it is clear that at bare minimum they view Rodgers as a better option than any other free agent QB, trading for another QB, AND a better option than the two QBs they had in-house already and would have presumably had first opportunity to extend with (Wilson - 1 yr 10.5m, Fields - 2 yrs 40m)

So once again I'll say, it would seem that there are only two possibilities here:

1.) The Steelers are indeed a well-run franchise and they are pursuing Rodgers because they believe a.) the drama is overblown, b.) his decline in play is exaggerated and/or will improve in their context, or c.) both

or 2.) The Steelers are in fact not as well-run as we have been led to believe and they are choosing to ignore all of the "red flags" around Rodgers and continue pursuing a deal with him.
 

Thirteen Below

Cheesehead
Joined
Jan 15, 2022
Messages
1,380
Reaction score
1,118
For me, the drafting of Love and how Rodgers reacted to it, was when the dark light started to really shine on Rodgers. Rodgers pretended to not be too upset about the pick, but his actions after that day said otherwise.
I actually like Rodgers; still do. Obviously he rubs me the wrong way sometimes, but he's like that old high school or college buddy who just annoys the hell out of you sometimes but nevertheless, you just can't help liking the guy. And I think a big part of that is because of the sheer joy I found watching him do his magic week in and week out, for 15 years of my life. IMO, the best pure passer I've seen since Marino.

I even went out of my way to watch Jets' games last season whenever I had the opportunity, just for the chance to see one or two more of those beautiful, absolutely perfect passes.

I'm just humbled by how fortunate we Packer fans are, to have 30 straight years of watching two of the most exciting quarterbacks ever to play the game. Even if they both do act like ****s every now and then, I'm still grateful to both of them for being such a big part of almost half my life.

But the snit ft he threw about Love... that's something I don't really respect. Just a couple of weeks before the draft, he was asked on the radio how he'd feel about Green Bay drafting a quarterback, and he said, "I'm a realist. I know where we're at as an organization, and I know where I'm at in my career. Anybody they bring in isn't going to beat me out anytime soon anyway".

And then when they do draft a developmental QB, his feelings are hurt.

I guess that just bothers me a bit.
 

Thirteen Below

Cheesehead
Joined
Jan 15, 2022
Messages
1,380
Reaction score
1,118
Even after I got my legs back, and the majority of my coordination, I was 59 years old and working towards playing. I wanted it. I wanted it DESPERATELY!!!! I'd substituted slow and fast pitch softball into my life the day after I quit playing baseball. The day I realized that I could no longer hang in there with the new kids on the block. They were beginning to be better than me.
I can relate to that; but with me it was/is hockey. I was still playing well into my 50s when I lived in the Twin Cities, and (to my surprise) pretty competitively. My conditioning was good, because I'd been a bicycle racer and 300-400 mile a week recreational rider well into my 40s until I developed a type of arthritis in my kneecap that was badly exacerbated by bicycling, and often hiked 40 miles or more per week on hilly terrain when i had to give up bicycles.

I'd obviously lost some speed, and some quickness (not always the same thing), but made up for a lot of that with experience and mental quickness. I played pickup games at Lake of the Isles in Minneapolis and Lake Phalen in St. Paul several nights a week, with guys sometimes half my age, and I don't think any of them saw me as a liability if we happened to be on the same team.

There was another fellow about 10 years older than I that played pretty regularly at both lakes, and they usually split us up, one "old guy" per team. But on the nights that we wound up playing together, we got a lot of surprised "whoas!!" from the kids when we connected on a play. That felt pretty good, although it was a big dropoff from back in the late 70s and early 80s when I sometimes played with some of the members of the "Miracle on Ice" team at Bloomington Ice Gardens.

Of course they were orders of magnitude better than I was, and had to throttle back quite a ways for some of us, but hell.... I was still playing with them, you know? I can remember like it was last night the time Neal Broten couldn't help himself, and positively undressed me with a move that I literally could not even see in real time. Up until a few years ago, I still exchanged Christmas cards every year with Phil Verchota.

Anyway, point is I could still play reasonably competitively in my 50s - just a different style of game. That's easier to do in hockey than baseball or softball. And I really believe I would still be playing if I hadn't moved to Kentucky to marry Amy.

But I can not deny I miss the feeling of playing at a really high level.

Bicycle racing, too.... damn, I remember the feeling of being in the groove; like I was just one with the bicycle.... I remember times that every single thing was perfectly synchronized, and my legs were like pistons, pumping down and pulling up, over and over again, my breathing in perfect harmony with the pedal strokes, my trunk twisting with each stroke, pulling upward on the bars to deliver maximum force on the alternating downstrokes, like I was more of a machine than a human... rocketing down hills at well over 45 MPH, hitting and holding 35 MPH on level roads, and seeing out of the corner of my eye the faces of the people going past me in cars.... just feeling like a machine that breathed in and out and pumped up and down.....

I'm not going to say I don't miss it, but my life is about different things now. I regret that I can no longer do that, but more than anything I'm grateful that I have the clear memories of having done it when I was able. At 67, I fear more than anything the loss of those memories; I hope that as I age, I can still enjoy savoring those longago experiences.

Oh - and Amy and I have been to Kentucky Horse Park several times, and I do recall seeing John henry in about 05 or 06. And just ambling through the pasture, grazing on the grass, I was struck by how he projected a casual air of "I'm John Henry... and you're not." Just majestic.
 

Latest posts

Top