Top 10:
1: Aaron Rodgers- anyone who doesn’t have Rodgers at #1 has an invalid list IMO. The fact he’s putting up MVP seasons this pre in his career with a poor supporting cast expresses his dominance.
2: Don Hudson- never got a chance to see him play but his numbers speak on his dominance. His TD record stood for 42 years and he averaged .85 TDs per game which is still a record to this day.
3: Reggie White- short lived Packer player but in terms of just pure dominance and talent he needs to be top 3.
4: Brett Favre- one of the all time great QBs. Say what you want about him and his turnovers but his toughness but at another level.
5: Sterling Sharpe- I do believe Sharpe was one of the most physically dominant receivers of all time. Speed, strength, and skill. If Reggie is in my top 3 for the same example of dominance I think it would be hypocritical for me to exclude Sharpe.
6: Bart Starr- tough to place Bart honesty. On one hand statistically he wasn’t very good but he was most certainly a winner.
7:Ray Nitschke- another player I never got to see play but just a true leader of a dominant defense that terrorized the league on its way to a multitude of championships.
8: Jim Taylor- statistically dominant runner that over the way for Lombardis offense. In a running error he was heads above the rest.
9: Charles Woodson- where I think Woodson truly shined was as a leader. That SB team didn’t really have a veteran leader. All the stars on that team were young up and comers. Woodson was the voice. A damn good player along the way as well.
10: Forrest Gregg- tough to keep some of these guys out but no respectable list has Gregg off it. He was too dominant compared to his peers in his era.
Worst:
1: Ahmad Carroll- by far to this day one of the worst CBs I’ve ever seen play the game.
2: Brian Brohm- Brohm was a 2nd round pick that couldn’t beat out a 7th round Matt Flynn and was quickly cut from the team after 1 year. This is truly the definition of a bum.
3: Jamal Reynolds- this guy was absolutely useless. And we traded up for him.
4: Bustin Harrell- what makes this pick so bad is everyone saw it coming. Injured player coming out and shouldn’t have been taken anywhere near where he was taken. He spent more time in the medical room than he did on the field.
5: Quinnen Rollins- this pick was baffling to me. The whole draft class was. Rollins was a basketball player too small and slow for the NBA so he tried football. Naturally he excelled at a poor football program but when he got to the league ge was what he was as a basketball player. Too small and slow. He was gone after 2 seasons.
6: Kevin King- I don’t want to hear it from the defenders. This guy is awful. Not only can he never be on the field, he’s poor when he’s on it, and he shows no heart. I have a bottle of scotch I’ve been saving since Kings the season I have been waiting to open upon his release. I thought it was to be last year… lord willing it will be opened in a few months.
7: Tony Mandarich- I’ve never believed he was as bad as everyone made him out to be. It was just those taken around him ended up being hall of famers and he became a **** burglar.
8: Datone Jones- A truly baffling pick. Not athletic enough to be an edge, not big enough to play 5 tech. He was basically useless. In fact we tried him at end and edge and he sucked at both.
9: Terrell Buckley- just not a good player taken in the top 5 and gone in 3 years.
10: Damarious Randall- this pick caused a chain reaction of decisions that would set the Packers back half a decade at least. In my opinion the all time worst attitude/poor player combo in my time watching. He was a bad player but blamed everyone but himself. Like Rollins, Randall was a baseball player. A very good outfielder who threw out his shoulder so transitioned to football where he excelled as a safety before playing CB his final year. Unfortunately the Packers wanted to play him as a CB where he struggled before ultimately being traded for peanuts before his rookie deal ended. This pick led to the departure of Hyde and Hayward. When Randall and Rollins failed it forced the selection of King. When King failed it forced the selection of Jaire and Jackson. When Jackson failed it forced the selection of Stokes.
1: Aaron Rodgers- anyone who doesn’t have Rodgers at #1 has an invalid list IMO. The fact he’s putting up MVP seasons this pre in his career with a poor supporting cast expresses his dominance.
2: Don Hudson- never got a chance to see him play but his numbers speak on his dominance. His TD record stood for 42 years and he averaged .85 TDs per game which is still a record to this day.
3: Reggie White- short lived Packer player but in terms of just pure dominance and talent he needs to be top 3.
4: Brett Favre- one of the all time great QBs. Say what you want about him and his turnovers but his toughness but at another level.
5: Sterling Sharpe- I do believe Sharpe was one of the most physically dominant receivers of all time. Speed, strength, and skill. If Reggie is in my top 3 for the same example of dominance I think it would be hypocritical for me to exclude Sharpe.
6: Bart Starr- tough to place Bart honesty. On one hand statistically he wasn’t very good but he was most certainly a winner.
7:Ray Nitschke- another player I never got to see play but just a true leader of a dominant defense that terrorized the league on its way to a multitude of championships.
8: Jim Taylor- statistically dominant runner that over the way for Lombardis offense. In a running error he was heads above the rest.
9: Charles Woodson- where I think Woodson truly shined was as a leader. That SB team didn’t really have a veteran leader. All the stars on that team were young up and comers. Woodson was the voice. A damn good player along the way as well.
10: Forrest Gregg- tough to keep some of these guys out but no respectable list has Gregg off it. He was too dominant compared to his peers in his era.
Worst:
1: Ahmad Carroll- by far to this day one of the worst CBs I’ve ever seen play the game.
2: Brian Brohm- Brohm was a 2nd round pick that couldn’t beat out a 7th round Matt Flynn and was quickly cut from the team after 1 year. This is truly the definition of a bum.
3: Jamal Reynolds- this guy was absolutely useless. And we traded up for him.
4: Bustin Harrell- what makes this pick so bad is everyone saw it coming. Injured player coming out and shouldn’t have been taken anywhere near where he was taken. He spent more time in the medical room than he did on the field.
5: Quinnen Rollins- this pick was baffling to me. The whole draft class was. Rollins was a basketball player too small and slow for the NBA so he tried football. Naturally he excelled at a poor football program but when he got to the league ge was what he was as a basketball player. Too small and slow. He was gone after 2 seasons.
6: Kevin King- I don’t want to hear it from the defenders. This guy is awful. Not only can he never be on the field, he’s poor when he’s on it, and he shows no heart. I have a bottle of scotch I’ve been saving since Kings the season I have been waiting to open upon his release. I thought it was to be last year… lord willing it will be opened in a few months.
7: Tony Mandarich- I’ve never believed he was as bad as everyone made him out to be. It was just those taken around him ended up being hall of famers and he became a **** burglar.
8: Datone Jones- A truly baffling pick. Not athletic enough to be an edge, not big enough to play 5 tech. He was basically useless. In fact we tried him at end and edge and he sucked at both.
9: Terrell Buckley- just not a good player taken in the top 5 and gone in 3 years.
10: Damarious Randall- this pick caused a chain reaction of decisions that would set the Packers back half a decade at least. In my opinion the all time worst attitude/poor player combo in my time watching. He was a bad player but blamed everyone but himself. Like Rollins, Randall was a baseball player. A very good outfielder who threw out his shoulder so transitioned to football where he excelled as a safety before playing CB his final year. Unfortunately the Packers wanted to play him as a CB where he struggled before ultimately being traded for peanuts before his rookie deal ended. This pick led to the departure of Hyde and Hayward. When Randall and Rollins failed it forced the selection of King. When King failed it forced the selection of Jaire and Jackson. When Jackson failed it forced the selection of Stokes.
