P@ck66 said:
(OK..I'll say this extra slow..so some of you guys can understand...are you listening Zero..Anubis..etc..? Good...)
ravage..this is especially for you..try to think in a straight line...nothing circular here...
OK..Hypothetically you have a team that has a HOF QB on it...that has performed at a very high level for 14 years..you have an off season...FA..and a draft coming up....
Do you....
A. Try to put together a team around your star player (your QB) through FA because you're not going have him for too much longer, and he is your best shot at your getting to the SB this year or the next while also drafting talent in positions where you need depth and rebuilding through the Draft?
or
B. Ignore the fact that you have such a player on your team and just focus on the draft because your goal is to win 3-4 years from now...??
My question is...if you choose B. , why can't you just wait until Favre retires to go into full-scale rebuild mode....there will be plenty of time for it?
If TT really cared about Favre and winning now..he would have tried to work something out with Javon.....sign a veteran like Moulds or TO....and concentrate on rebuilding the O-Line throughn FA.., the draft, and roster cuts after June 1st...THAT would have been a very good plan to be competitive NOW...
but he didn't do ANY of that....and my question to you is this....
What if TT "master plan" doesn't work out and after 3-4 years the Pack is just a .500 team...and Brett Favre is long into retirement...Do you think all of TT's moves will have been worth it...??
It could very well happen....
You cannot deny the fact that TT dropped the ball in FA because all he really cares about is the draft....
This is not how Denver treated Elway in his final years....
Think about it...
First I want to thank for writing your post slowly. I'm sure I would have had a hard time reading had you written it quickly.
Great hypothetical situation you have there. Only one problem you base your entire situation on Favre being a Packer. If I'm not mistaken Favre was talking of retirement. TT had no guarantee that no matter who he signed that Favre would come back. So the decision for TT is does he overpay for some quick fix veteran on the premise that maybe Favre comes back then? In the world of business you won't last long with maybes. Believe me the NFL is at least as much a business as it a sport, if not more.
So as far as your hypothetical situation goes it's totally irrelevant due to your basing the arguement on the assurity that Favre was returning.
As far as Javon goes, the one thing I've heard is, that once it was announced Favre would be back, there was no way Javon would be back. Just rumors mind you but with how Favre climbed on the antiholdout bandwagon last year. I can see how Javon would get a hair up his butt about playing with him again.
The future of the Packers is far from assured, no doubt about that. But as for the future I'll take my chances with a bunch of young players trying to make their mark along with the team veterans to show them the way. Rather than having a roster of used up and overpaid FAs that we picked up along the way. Big name FAs guarantee as much as a rookie, nothing. Personally I'd rather have the kids.
At the same time I'd rather have Favre over Rodgers. Welcome back, Brett. Oh and one last thing that you and I can agree on, Brett Favre will be a HOF member, no doubt and deservedly so.