On the interception Rodgers should have waited another second to throw the ball, Shepherd would have been wide open in the end zone.
I saw him coming open, but I was way at the other end of the field so when I yelled to Rodgers I don't think he heard me. But that's as wide open as you could be and it wasn't because Rodgers was throwing to MVS, all the defenders commited to him already. Shepherd would have stood there and caught the ball.
You guys are seeing something that is not there.
I'm looking at this play right now is super slo-mo with freeze frames. It's a called quick-timing pick play. When I freeze it at the point where Rodgers' arm is starting forward Shepherd is still rubbing the inside defender. #38, the outside defender, is squared up to Shepard's path.
If you didn't already know what happened next, from that freeze frame you would say the inside defender is in position to take MVS with the rub looking like the play will work while #38, the outside defender, is in position to take Shepherd to the outside. With the ball then in the air, Shepard is still engaged with the inside defender.
#38 made a nice read and cut inside to take MVS. It was a good play design and well executed, because even with that good defensive read by #38 he was still trailing, then mis-timed his defense of the throw initially contacting MVS with the ball still 3 yards from reaching MVS. By the time the ball gets to MVS he's already wrapped up.
There are two possible complaints that can be made:
1) It was pass interference. On another day with a different ref in position to make the call, you might get the call. In real time it was bang-bang, and refs are not inclined to make game-altering decisions is the closing seconds, which is how we got this PI review rule in the first place which doesn't seem to be working very well.
2) You could complain that it was not a good play call, though I would not agree.
If you want Shepherd to see the ball on this play, you should send a memo to LaFluer, cc: Aaron Rodgers saying:
1) Guess both defenders will go to MVS.
2) Rodgers should have eyes inside and give a little pump fake there, then throw to the wide open Shepherd.
That, of course, requires the guess being right.
I had been listening to a lot of b*tching that the McCarthy/Rodgers' the lack of commitment to timing throws out of combination routes, Rodgers breaking with the program to extend plays, and that the LaFleur offense will fix this if only Rodgers will get with the program. Well, here you have it, and we're still b*tching?