2025 Roster - Semi Live Thread

[tynimiller]

As of typing this original post (2/24/25) the plan is to keep this as live as possible (within a week or so at the oldest) and will for sure during big news time frames try to keep it updated within the day.

Roster As of 3/4/2025 - last update McManus signed

Bold are guys on roster heading into off season/FA

Quarterbacks
Jordan Love - Signed through 2028 season
Malik Willis - Final year of contract
Sean Clifford - Final year of contract

Running Backs
Josh Jacobs - Signed through 2027 season
Marshawn Lloyd - Signed through 2027 season
Chris Brooks - Final year

Wide Receivers
Romeo Doubs - Final year
Christian Watson - Final year *if injured all year contract could toll
Jayden Reed - Signed through 2026 season
Dontayvion Wicks - Signed through 2026 season
Malike Heath - Final year
Lideatrick Griffin - Final year
Julian Hicks - Final year
Cornelius Johnson - Final year

Tight Ends
Tucker Kraft - signed through 2026 season
Luke Musgrave - signed through 2026 season
Ben Sims - Final year
Messiah Swinson - Final year
Johnny Lumpkin - Final year

Offensive Line
Elgton Jenkins - Signed through 2026 season
Zach Tom - Final year
Jordan Morgan - Signed through 2027 season
Rasheed Walker - Final year
Sean Rhyan - Final year
Trey Hill - Final year
Jacob Monk - Signed through 2027
Travis Glover - Signed through 2027
Marquis Hayes - Final year
Donovan Jennings - Final year

Defensive Line
Kenny Clark - Signed through 2027 season
Devonte Wyatt - Final year *option open I believe for 2026 at time of typing
Colby Wooden - Signed through 2026 season
Karl Brooks - Signed through 2026 season
Nesta Jade Silvera - Final year
Deslin Alexandre - Final year
James Ester - Final year
Jeremiah Martin - Final year
Leonard Payne - Final year
Keith Randolph - Final year

Edges
Rashan Gary - Signed through 2027 season
LVN - Signed through 2026 (option 2027)
Kingsley Enagbare - Final year
Brenton Cox - Final year
Off Ball LBs
Quay Walker - Final year *option open I believe for 2026 at time of typing
Egerrin Cooper - Signed through 2027
Ty'Ron Hopper - Signed through 2027
Isaiah McDuffie - 3/3/25Signed 2 year $8M deal.

Secondary
Jaire Alexander - Signed through 2026
Xavier McKinney - Signed through 2027
Keisean Nixon - Signed through 2026
Javon Bullard - Signed through 2027
Evan Williams - Signed through 2027
Carrington Valentine - Signed through 2026
Isaiah Dunn - Final year
Kitan Oladapo - Signed through 2027
Omar Brown - Final year
Kamal Hadden - Final year
Kaleb Hayes - Final year
Kalen King - Final year

Special Teams
Matthew Orzech LS - Final year
Alex Hale K - Final year
Brandon McManus - Signed 3/4/2025

 

[tynimiller]

@Pokerbrat2000 here ya go.

@Poppa San could you unsticky the old 2024 one and sticky this one?

 

[tynimiller]

Isaiah McDuffie News - Gute doing insurance Gute type things. Signed to a 2 year $8M deal (incentives could climb it to $9.5M) $4m/yr deal with likely I bet a 2M-3M hit this year...DEPENDING what his signing bonus is it could be a one year deal essentially.

Amended OP to reflect as I confirmed with two trusted sources.

 

[tynimiller]

FTR, spotrac says Packers got a slight deal:

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

 

[Sanguine camper]

The main conclusion from the McDuffie signing is that the LB position will likely be a low priority for much change heading into 2025. If Cooper and Walker are going to take the big majority of snaps, where does McDuffie fit in? Wilson is better on special teams and Hopper is a third round pick. Draft picks that high don't ordinarily sit on the bench too long. Would McDuffie take snaps away from Cooper and Walker and Wilson on special teams? I hope not. While Wilson is a free agent, resigning him makes sense from a special teams perspective.

The only scenario that makes sense is the front office sees McDuffie as a much better back up than Hopper should Walker or Cooper be out with an injury. That would provide a lot of justification to the folks who decried the Hopper selection last year calling him a wasted pick.

 

[tynimiller]

I think folks are over reading the McDuffie signing. Solid against the run, played well when needed this past couple seasons, limited in pass pro for sure but that isn’t when you’ll have him out there a ton.

This contract is not much at all and structure wise could really be a one year deal and zero tied to him or close to.

 

[gopkrs]

I think folks are over reading the McDuffie signing. Solid against the run, played well when needed this past couple seasons, limited in pass pro for sure but that isn’t when you’ll have him out there a ton.

This contract is not much at all and structure wise could really be a one year deal and zero tied to him or close to.

Yeah. You gotta have some players that you know. I'm not reading a lot into it either. Except maybe no Wilson. But we still need another linebacker. We could draft one.

 

[tynimiller]

Crazy stat for everyone….McDuffie played more 2024 snaps than Clark and Gary….

 

[tynimiller]

Yeah. You gotta have some players that you know. I'm not reading a lot into it either. Except maybe no Wilson. But we still need another linebacker. We could draft one.

I think we have our four of five and Gute could draft or we could see a low level resign like Wilson back even post draft

 

[Sanguine camper]

Gute could've let McDuffie walk and used the money to sign free agents or extend guys on the roster. While by today's NFL salary standards, McDuffie' money is very modest, it still posses an opportunity cost.

While the total of his contract has been reported, no word yet on the signing bonus which would really be the team's commitment should Hopper step up and cause McDuffie to be expendable and cut later in training camp.

 

[tynimiller]

Gute could've let McDuffie walk and used the money to sign free agents or extend guys on the roster. While by today's NFL salary standards, McDuffie' money is very modest, it still posses an opportunity cost.

While the total of his contract has been reported, no word yet on the signing bonus which would really be the team's commitment should Hopper step up and cause McDuffie to be expendable and cut later in training camp.

Role guys like this never get over 20-30% give or take in GB - which likely means we are committing one real year to McDuffie with the out of keeping him if he balled out this year…but he isn’t gonna play a ton unless the room has injury.

Also everyone, you as well, knew either Eric Wilson or McDuffie was being resigned. We have only two guys on roster with significant actual game snaps, and Hopper. One of them was getting resigned and both still may.

 

[OldSchool101]

McDuffie has been a solid purchase in RD5. He’s everything you expect from a mid Day3 LB. Not overly flashy, but he wears well. Core Teams guy with ability to rotate in at starting LB as a contingency without a a major dropoff. I think $4Mil is very fair for his services.
For myself, I see this as more of the filling in of smaller cracks so we can focus on key positions without financial distraction. Great teammate with a lunch pale work ethic. He’s a Reliable player from several angles.
Congrats to McDuffie he’s earned this!

 

[Sanguine camper]

Most backup LB's in the NFL are on their rookie contract making about 2 million per year or less. Again, I think the McDuffie signing shows a huge lack of confidence in Hopper and a draft priority in 2025 that doesn't include a LB in the first 5 rounds. Otherwise, Gute could've drafted a LB and let McDuffie walk, saving a couple million per year. McDuffie is a back up LB who struggles mightily in the passing game. Guys like that are a dime a dozen in the NFL.

I'm not knocking Gute but ad it up and conclude that he needed to sign McDuffie for the reasons above.

 

[OldSchool101]

Most backup LB's in the NFL are on their rookie contract making about 2 million per year or less. Again, I think the McDuffie signing shows a huge lack of confidence in Hopper and a draft priority in 2025 that doesn't include a LB in the first 5 rounds. Otherwise, Gute could've drafted a LB and let McDuffie walk, saving a couple million per year. McDuffie is a back up LB who struggles mightily in the passing game. Guys like that are a dime a dozen in the NFL.

I'm not knocking Gute but ad it up and conclude that he needed to sign McDuffie for the reasons above.

That’s one angle.
I just think he’s a guy that has nearly 100 tackles on a Defense that imo supersedes any D we’ve had in 15 years. He does what he’s asked (weakside strongside or Teams) and at a Starter level. His ties to Haf likely influenced this. Yet I think Jeff Hafley earned the right to choose his players and I think he was involved in that decision. I think you guys would agree Jeff Hafley knows what he’s doing.

I just like we don’t get yanked too many different directions as we reinforce our roster. All the way back to my playing Army guys as a kid, this has the scent of staying with what has worked and reinforcing a segment of the D. That move is essentially at worst our 3 Starting LB crew and a pretty good one at that. Not saying we can’t grab one or add depth, but it absolutely pushed LB need to minimal.

Now let’s go get at least 2 of 3 of a premier or + Starter at Edge, CB or WR.

 

[tynimiller]

Most backup LB's in the NFL are on their rookie contract making about 2 million per year or less. Again, I think the McDuffie signing shows a huge lack of confidence in Hopper and a draft priority in 2025 that doesn't include a LB in the first 5 rounds. Otherwise, Gute could've drafted a LB and let McDuffie walk, saving a couple million per year. McDuffie is a back up LB who struggles mightily in the passing game. Guys like that are a dime a dozen in the NFL.

I'm not knocking Gute but ad it up and conclude that he needed to sign McDuffie for the reasons above.

This is why you give a guy that has proven NFL capable as a back up and honestly the last two seasons and a solid contributor on teams truly a rather cheap contract likely with a structure that is not anywhere close to high until next season and even than likely $5-$6M which only way you let him see that year is if he's yet again a starter and yet again continues to help this defense progress even more.

He's started for us 25 times over the last two seasons; only Clark, Slaton, Gary, Nixon and Walker of current Packers has seen more starts.
He saw more snaps this last year than Rashan Gary even.

These guys that in a moment's notice can come in and the drop off is minimal in many aspects of the game are exactly the type of guys you try to flesh your roster out with - ESPECIALLY during time frames where the rest of the room is made up of rookie type contracts. The structure of this deal I would bet my life on doesn't put a ton of commitment past 2025, but keeps his 2026 number low incase say Quay leaves in FA and Hopper doesn't progress and a rookie drafted this year or next isn't ready.

This pick allows Gute to still draft a LB if one at the spot when on the clock makes sense and not bat an eye...again because McDuffie being in house has immense value this year, but may not be needed next season at all. This signing doesn't change that.

I mentioned it before here and have in the past in reflections of games - McDuffie is a known commodity, and as a coach there is immense value in having some players like that - especially in specific roles or off the bench. I played a lot of basketball growing up, BUT I wasn't the ball handler in the sense of breaking ankles, nor was I the best shooter...I wasn't the quickest defender either...however I often ran point because I was smart with the basketball, knew the offensive responsibilities for every position except the 2 (even that one I knew I just never ran plays in it usually) and was tasked with playing defense typically against their best guy. I never understood it really until my coach told me I know you know precisely your responsibility and you will execute it...even if you get beat on defense you know to immediately fall to where your helpside ought to be coming from...you know where and how to execute, if beat it isn't from being dumb it is purely your guy beat you. <-- That is McDuffie to a 'T' IMO. He is rarely beat because he made a bad decision or read things wrong or blew his assignment - no he gets beat purely because his assignment is more athletic or just quicker.

I predict his structure is something like $2.5M hit 2025 and $5.5M in 2026 with only like $2M guarantee and nearly nothing on the line in 2026....even the staunchest McDuffie critics cannot deny he's easily worth that.

 

[Sanguine camper]

This is why you give a guy that has proven NFL capable as a back up and honestly the last two seasons and a solid contributor on teams truly a rather cheap contract likely with a structure that is not anywhere close to high until next season and even than likely $5-$6M which only way you let him see that year is if he's yet again a starter and yet again continues to help this defense progress even more.

He's started for us 25 times over the last two seasons; only Clark, Slaton, Gary, Nixon and Walker of current Packers has seen more starts.
He saw more snaps this last year than Rashan Gary even.

These guys that in a moment's notice can come in and the drop off is minimal in many aspects of the game are exactly the type of guys you try to flesh your roster out with - ESPECIALLY during time frames where the rest of the room is made up of rookie type contracts. The structure of this deal I would bet my life on doesn't put a ton of commitment past 2025, but keeps his 2026 number low incase say Quay leaves in FA and Hopper doesn't progress and a rookie drafted this year or next isn't ready.

This pick allows Gute to still draft a LB if one at the spot when on the clock makes sense and not bat an eye...again because McDuffie being in house has immense value this year, but may not be needed next season at all. This signing doesn't change that.

I mentioned it before here and have in the past in reflections of games - McDuffie is a known commodity, and as a coach there is immense value in having some players like that - especially in specific roles or off the bench. I played a lot of basketball growing up, BUT I wasn't the ball handler in the sense of breaking ankles, nor was I the best shooter...I wasn't the quickest defender either...however I often ran point because I was smart with the basketball, knew the offensive responsibilities for every position except the 2 (even that one I knew I just never ran plays in it usually) and was tasked with playing defense typically against their best guy. I never understood it really until my coach told me I know you know precisely your responsibility and you will execute it...even if you get beat on defense you know to immediately fall to where your helpside ought to be coming from...you know where and how to execute, if beat it isn't from being dumb it is purely your guy beat you. <-- That is McDuffie to a 'T' IMO. He is rarely beat because he made a bad decision or read things wrong or blew his assignment - no he gets beat purely because his assignment is more athletic or just quicker.

I predict his structure is something like $2.5M hit 2025 and $5.5M in 2026 with only like $2M guarantee and nearly nothing on the line in 2026....even the staunchest McDuffie critics cannot deny he's easily worth that.

I guess we just disagree on McDuffie's ability. I see him as easily replaceable and a big liability in the passing game. While I don't doubt he's very familiar with Hafley's defense, he was still targeted in the passing game. With a 53 man roster, decisions are always going to get very interconnected. If Hopper evoked any confidence as a good no 3 LB, I doubt Gute would've spent the extra funds to keep McDuffie around. I just hope this is all very meaningless because Cooper and Walker have monster seasons next year.

 

[tynimiller]

I guess we just disagree on McDuffie's ability. I see him as easily replaceable and a big liability in the passing game. While I don't doubt he's very familiar with Hafley's defense, he was still targeted in the passing game. With a 53 man roster, decisions are always going to get very interconnected. If Hopper evoked any confidence as a good no 3 LB, I doubt Gute would've spent the extra funds to keep McDuffie around. I just hope this is all very meaningless because Cooper and Walker have monster seasons next year.

Not gonna lie never noticed or felt he saw an elevated amount of targets but was clueless so looked our four off ball guys' 2024 numbers up:

McDuffie 2024 : Coverage Snaps - 379 / Targeted 64 or 16.8% of CovSn / Gave up 566 yards
Q Walker 2024 : Coverage Snaps - 425 / Targeted 52 or 12.2% of CovSn / Gave up 373 yards
E Cooper 2024 : Coverage Snaps - 274 / Targeted 46 or 16.8% of CovSn / Gave up 341 yards
E Wilson 2024 : Coverage Snaps - 279 / Targeted 35 or 12.5% of Covsn / Gave up 277 Yards

If McDuffie was athletic enough to be better in pass pro he's easily a $8M/yr or more off ball backer in the league....and that is of course why his contract is as low as it is I'm sure.

 

[El Guapo]

Great stats. It shows that opposing QBs were no different than a wolf in the wild. They picked on the young and the weak in Cooper and McDuffie. Isaiah is a solid situational LB, an okay backup, and from what I understand a good guy in the locker room. I am fine with this signing as you need solid backups. Hafley needs to devise some schemes to help out McDuffie in coverage.

Hopefully Sean Duggan works hard with McDuffie to shore up his weak points.

 

[tynimiller]

McManus stole for $15.5M/3 Years

INSANELY GOOD DEAL FOLKS