PFF Top / Bottom 5 (Regular Season 2024/25)

[Magooch]

Not going to bother with the actual numerical scores, but we have had the top/bottom five players on offense defense posted each week. I posted this thread over the bye week for a midseason review...Here is updated to include the whole regular season. It is just counting number of appearances in the top and/or bottom five on offense/defense.

Top-5 Offense Appearances
13 - ZACH TOM
11 - Josh Jacobs
8 - Emanuel Wilson, Jayden Reed, Jordan Love
6 - Elgton Jenkins
4 - Dontayvion Wicks, Rasheed Walker, Romeo Doubs
3 - Ben Sims, Chris Brooks, Malik Willis, Tucker Kraft
2 - Christian Watson, Jordan Morgan
1 - Josh Myers, Malik Heath, Sean Rhyan

Top-5 Defense Appearances
8 - EDGERRIN COOPER
7 - Xavier McKinney
5- Eric Stokes, Jaire Alexander, Javon Bullard
4 - Carrington Valentine, Isaiah McDuffie, Keisean Nixon, Kenny Clark, Preston Smith, Quay Walker, Rashan Gary
3 - Devonte Wyatt, Eric Wilson, Evan Williams, Karl Brooks, Lukas Van Ness, TJ Slaton
2 - Arron Mosby, Brenton Cox, Kingsley Enagbare, Zayne Anderson
1 - Kitan Oladapo

Bottom-5 Offense Appearances
7 - Tucker Kraft, Sean Rhyan, Josh Myers, Christian Watson, Ben Sims
6 - Rasheed Walker, Elgton Jenkins
5 - Jayden Reed, Dontayvion Wicks, Bo Melton
4 - Luke Musgrave
3 - Romeo Doubs, Malik Heath, Chris Brooks
2 - Zach Tom, Jordan Morgan, Jordan Love
1 - Marshawn Lloyd, Malik Willis, Josh Jacobs, John FitzPatrick

Bottom-5 Defense Appearances
8 - Colby Wooden, Kingsley Enagbare
7 - TJ Slaton
6 - Javon Bullard, Karl Brooks, Kenny Clark
5 - Devonte Wyatt, Eric Wilson, Lukas Van Ness, Quay Walker
4 - Isaiah McDuffie
3 - Eric Stokes, Keisean Nixon, Preston Smith
2 - Arron Mosby, Carrington Valentine, Edgerrin Cooper, Evan Williams, Rashan Gary
1 - Brenton Cox, Xavier McKinney

Make of it what you will!

 

[El Guapo]

Steve McCroskey:
Johnny, what can you make out of this?

Johnny:
This? Why, I can make a hat or a brooch or a pterodactyl...

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

 

[El Guapo]

I think that what you posted is a clear guideline to whom you keep and whom the Packers should move on from, if possible. Nice job

 

[SudsMcBucky]

Elgton Jenkins looks to have been feast or famine.

 

[DoURant]

Shocking to see Tucker Kraft on the bottom 5 offense, checking and re-checks notes....7 times

Jaire played 7 games, and was Top 5 in 5 of those, proving if he can stay on the field, he is still one of the best.

Rashan Gary had 4 Top 5 appearances, and only 2 Bottom 5 ( the least of all our DL) .... which tells me was a solid performer every week, but maybe not what we expect or want from a guy being paid a lot. However, he gets more hate than he should, because everyone just looks at his sack total, and not what he does in the running game.

Shout out to Emanual Wilson, our backup RB, who made the Top 5, 8 times.... proving that a guy who played College football for the Johnson C. Smith Golden Bulls, and the Fort Valley St Wildcats, can play in this league, and be impactful.

 

[tynimiller]

Shocking to see Tucker Kraft on the bottom 5 offense, checking and re-checks notes....7 times

Jaire played 7 games, and was Top 5 in 5 of those, proving if he can stay on the field, he is still one of the best.

Rashan Gary had 4 Top 5 appearances, and only 2 Bottom 5 ( the least of all our DL) .... which tells me was a solid performer every week, but maybe not what we expect or want from a guy being paid a lot. However, he gets more hate than he should, because everyone just looks at his sack total, and not what he does in the running game.

Shout out to Emanual Wilson, our backup RB, who made the Top 5, 8 times.... proving that a guy who played College football for the Johnson C. Smith Golden Bulls, and the Fort Valley St Wildcats, can play in this league, and be impactful.

Kraft, some forget he’s asked to do a LOT of different things in a game, arguably more than anyone else…he’s a run blocker, pass blocker, short and intermediate route runner/receiver, in line, split wide, even motioned into the backfield, QB sneaks….thats a LOT of chances to be graded in a very different way, sometimes multiple in one play.

Kraft is special and I personally think that he and Love have a REAL chance to be the absolute best offensive picks of Gutes career when we look back on it

 

[DoURant]

Kraft, some forget he’s asked to do a LOT of different things in a game, arguably more than anyone else…he’s a run blocker, pass blocker, short and intermediate route runner/receiver, in line, split wide, even motioned into the backfield, QB sneaks….thats a LOT of chances to be graded in a very different way, sometimes multiple in one play.

Kraft is special and I personally think that he and Love have a REAL chance to be the absolute best offensive picks of Gutes career when we look back on it

Just to be clear to everyone, I wasn't slighting him, and I knowTyni didn't take it that way either. It just seemed crazy to see him on that list.

I read this week where Kraft said he wants to be more of a leader next year, and I think that's awesome, because we need more leaders on the team.