Would you rather?

[ivo610]

Its draft day and I am very excited. So to kill some time for the next 6 or so hours I figured we could play would you rather. Someone throws up two picks, doesnt have to be the same position, just projected to go in the area of the draft. Another poster picks who he thinks of the two is going to be the better pro and why. Then throws up some more picks. This might not catch on but I figured I would give it a shot.

Don banks of SI has us taking Mike Iupati and Peter King of SI has us taking Sergio Kindle. Which one should we take if given the choice?

 

[melvin2006]

Iupati hands down. defense was pretty good last season, the O-line was not. rodgers need to be on his feet with a clean jersey. i still think there is a decent chance we trade up to around 12 or so and get bulaga if he is there

 

[ehoepker]

Sergio Kindle. I think he'd be great playing on the opposite side of CM3

 

[profile_removed]

I would rather have Tony ManImRich again than any OUTSIDE linebacker. We need help inside not outside.

 

[ivo610]

Iupati hands down. defense was pretty good last season, the O-line was not. rodgers need to be on his feet with a clean jersey. i still think there is a decent chance we trade up to around 12 or so and get bulaga if he is there

You think its worth giving up a 1st, 2nd, and 3rd to do that? Thats what the values come out as with the number system the league uses.

 

[PackersRS]

Kindle.

I was in love with Iupati in the beginning of march (there's a thread were I predict he'll be the pick). But the fact that he only played against lesser competition, is very raw, and that when he did play against better comp. (senior bowl), though he was dislocated (RG, not LG), he struggled mightly in the pass pro, and had to hold his way out of not being beat. That scares me.

Kindle seems like the better fit for the LOLB, as he's the best rush defender OLB in the draft, and is very good rushing the passer, and is an adequate cover man. I find him a little stiff, but he's a player, as good as Orakpo...

Now my question: Charles Brown or Kyle Wilson?

 

[ivo610]

Tim Tebow or Colt Mccoy?

 

[PackersRS]

You think its worth giving up a 1st, 2nd, and 3rd to do that? Thats what the values come out as with the number system the league uses.

Value system in a regular draft... Not in a deep draft, with a team wanting to trade down...

I know not every team has Mangenius, but look for what the Browns traded the 5th pick..

 

[ivo610]

Kindle.

I was in love with Iupati in the beginning of march (there's a thread were I predict he'll be the pick). But the fact that he only played against lesser competition, is very raw, and that when he did play against better comp. (senior bowl), though he was dislocated (RG, not LG), he struggled mightly in the pass pro, and had to hold his way out of not being beat. That scares me.

Kindle seems like the better fit for the LOLB, as he's the best rush defender OLB in the draft, and is very good rushing the passer, and is an adequate cover man. I find him a little stiff, but he's a player, as good as Orakpo...

Now my question: Charles Brown or Kyle Wilson?

Good breakdown on Iupati. Its funny how a month will change your perspective on a player. I have that happen every year.

Kyle Wilson, but not because I am overly high on him (I havent watched much film on him), but because I dont like Brown that much. He struggles against speed and Jared Allen would eat him alive.

 

[ivo610]

Value system in a regular draft... Not in a deep draft, with a team wanting to trade down...

I know not every team has Mangenius, but look for what the Browns traded the 5th pick..

It seems to be the standard currency of the past two decades for the draft, and I cant imagine a team letting up move up that high for anything less. But all it takes is one team. Ted loves his late picks, so with a deep draft its hard to see that happening.

 

[PackersRS]

Tim Tebow or Colt Mccoy?

Damn, that's a hard one... Depends on what I have. If I can wait for 3 years, Tebow. If it has to pan out earlier, and I have a spread system, McCoy.

Don't like either as a QB right now...

 

[lancer84]

Don banks of SI has us taking Mike Iupati and Peter King of SI has us taking Sergio Kindle. Which one should we take if given the choice?

Tim Tebow or Colt Mccoy?

Sergio Kindle, would love to see him on the other side of CM3 and also because Iupati...eh we could do better than that if we got a pick that early.

Tebow for sure...I don't know what it is about McCoy but something rubs me the wrong way about him.

 

[Jess]

Now my question: Charles Brown or Kyle Wilson?

Wilson. We all know how much I want a corner.

Tim Tebow or Colt Mccoy?

Tebow. He can play the wildcat. His vesatility means more to us than anything McCoy would bring.

Don banks of SI has us taking Mike Iupati and Peter King of SI has us taking Sergio Kindle. Which one should we take if given the choice?

Iupati. I like what I saw out of Brad Jones last year, I don't think OLB is a first round need.

C.J. Spiller or Joe Haden? It's the trade up scenario.

 

[PackersRS]

Wilson. We all know how much I want a corner.


Tebow. He can play the wildcat. His vesatility means more to us than anything McCoy would bring.


Iupati. I like what I saw out of Brad Jones last year, I don't think OLB is a first round need.

C.J. Spiller or Joe Haden? It's the trade up scenario.

Haden. I really, really like Haden.

 

[ivo610]

Wilson. We all know how much I want a corner.


Tebow. He can play the wildcat. His vesatility means more to us than anything McCoy would bring.


Iupati. I like what I saw out of Brad Jones last year, I don't think OLB is a first round need.

C.J. Spiller or Joe Haden? It's the trade up scenario.

Hadden. He is an elite player I think

 

[ivo610]

Eric Berry or Brian Bulaga

 

[Jess]

Berry. Draft him and we're set at that position for the next 10 years with a guy that I think will be one of the best in the NFL in a short amount of time.

 

[Jess]

Bringing this topic back to life:

Dez Bryant or a Tackle and Dexter McCluster later in the draft?

 

[PackersRS]

Eric Berry or Brian Bulaga

No question in here, it's Berry by miles and miles...

Bringing this topic back to life:

Dez Bryant or a Tackle and Dexter McCluster later in the draft?

Didn't get it. Explain it better, please...

 

[Jess]

No question in here, it's Berry by miles and miles...

Didn't get it. Explain it better, please...

You're right, that wording sucked.

Would you rather trade up and take the explosive Dez Bryant, or stay at 23 and take the best Left Tackle available as well as taking Dexter McCluster later to satisfy the need for a return man.

 

[PackersRS]

You're right, that wording sucked.

Would you rather trade up and take the explosive Dez Bryant, or stay at 23 and take the best Left Tackle available as well as taking Dexter McCluster later to satisfy the need for a return man.

OH.

Wow, again, no question, if we move up to take Bryant, heck IF WE TAKE BRYANT, I'd be quite pissed. Not as much as with Mays, but still...

Unless, of course, he proves to be a great player and we win the SB. But even if Bryant proves to be a great player and we lose because of our OL or D, TT should go...

 

[ivo610]

I want no part of Bryant

 

[ivo610]

Eric Decker or Toby Gerhart

 

[Jess]

Would "Gerhart, because I've actually heard of him" be a lame answer?

 

[PackersRS]

Would "Gerhart, because I've actually heard of him" be a lame answer?

Yes. And it's also mine.