If he is fast.....has a great work ethic......is dedicated to football/the team, has the physical skills, makes devastating hits.....well.......if he is smart and coachable........hmmmm.........sounds like a SF 49er that use to play awhile back that receivers feared and made their arms look like those of a T-Rex. Doesn't sound like a bad thing at all.
If soemone wants to tell me he has been burned on many occasions.........well.......go back and look at Al Harris on Plaxico Burress in the Packer/Giants playoff game a few years back. Hell.......Jarrett Bush could have covered Burress better. (and that is jacked up to say) First of all....this guy is a safety not a corner.....but Mays, with some coaching should with out a doubt...be able to cover a running back or a tight end, support the run........or even blitz. Adrian Peterson will not Punk this guy.
I understand what you're saying but we were #1 in the league against the run last year.
We don't need another run supporter, we need someone than can cover and make our pass defense better.
And just for the sake of argument, Ahmad Carroll had all the physical tools in a corner. Tony Mandarich was one of the most physically gifted LTs there was...
He just doesn't have ball skills. You know when the ball is up in the air and Bush just doesnt know where it is, and it lands on the receiver, and Bush looks stupid??? Yeah, that's ball skills.
Now, he may just've had an awful, terrible, abysmal college season as a pass defender (and taking angles in run support, though he's much better at that).
But I don't know if his great junior season was because he had CM3, Cushing, Maualuga, Griffen, etc... making it easier.
All I know is that his senior year's showing wasn't of a promising S in the NFL...
In his entire college career, he only had 1 Fumble Forced and 5 ints.
http://espndb.go.com/ncf/player/profile?playerId=183232
He just doesn't make plays. He just hits hard, and a lot of times misses. A LOT OF TIMES.