Magooch's latest activity
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Packers vs Bears Game Thread: Make the Bears Continue to Suck edition.Ok, so either you don't understand the NFL rulebook or you don't understand how AI works, or both, I guess. You're gonna want to click...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Studs & Duds in Chicago.Any kind of incidental contact that occurs in the "natural course of play", i.e. scrums and, you know, every sort of scrimmage-blocking...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Studs & Duds in Chicago.Speaking of trusting Pat regarding the kicking game then I'm sure you would be inclined to trust former Bears LS Pat Mannelly on 670...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Studs & Duds in Chicago.Well the penalty you're asking for would be a 15 yard one, for starters. Again, learn the rules.
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Packers vs Bears Game Thread: Make the Bears Continue to Suck edition.Are you even reading what I've said? The AI summary you keep linking is literally referencing aiding the offensive player. Show me...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Studs & Duds in Chicago.Yeah, that's what I was going to say. It's a case of common sense - spirit of the law vs letter of the law. If we wanted to call every...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Studs & Duds in Chicago.as far as I can tell, I don't know if there's a firm "one second" rule in place either. I think that's what it's practically interpreted...
-
MHonestly, the more I dive into the rules and as @Magooch points out, what LVN did wasn't a penalty. What I did miss is this and it is...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Studs & Duds in Chicago.This is the way it has always been called as well: leverage is something you do yourself, not something that is done to you, if that...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Packers vs Bears Game Thread: Make the Bears Continue to Suck edition.Yes, if it's the play I'm thinking of I'm pretty sure he even looked right at the ref as though he was expecting a whistle, lol And...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Packers vs Bears Game Thread: Make the Bears Continue to Suck edition.Once again: read the rulebook and get back to me. Did Bruschi say which rule was broken? Somehow I doubt it. The only remotely...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Packers vs Bears Game Thread: Make the Bears Continue to Suck edition.To be fair LVN himself *did* say he got hands on Brooks and pushed him as best he could. But it doesn’t matter. It’s legal.
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Packers vs Bears Game Thread: Make the Bears Continue to Suck edition.Again I’ll say: show me which rule says a DEFENDER cannot push or “lift” a teammate. I’ll wait.
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Packers vs Bears Game Thread: Make the Bears Continue to Suck edition.Wrong and wrong again. This isn’t college. You CAN hit the long snapper. Rule 12/3/1m,n. You CAN push a teammate as a defender. It...
-
MMagooch replied to the thread Studs & Duds in Chicago.Two things: 1. This is not at all what Eberflus’ complaint is about 2. Your interpretation of the rule is incorrect. Not sure if...
